Most modern writing advice says to blast out a terrible first draft and fix it later. This approach, known as “discovery writing,” “writing by the seat of your pants,” or “pantising,” is brand new.
Nobody wrote books this way before word processors existed. Rewriting a novel meant retyping hundreds of pages by hand for every revision.
Most writers did something else before they wrote chapter one.
They planned.
Authors of previous generations viewed discovery writing the same way modern writers view kids these days who are using AI to write a novel. Back in the day, that “newfangled pantsing approach” created nothing but slush, which was the old-timey word for slop.
To be fair, you can write a good novel by the seat of your pants. Many bestselling novels have been written this way, and word processors have enabled far more people to write novels than the typewriter era did.
But pantsing doesn't work for everyone. If your drafts sag in the middle, meander, or turn out too similar to your last book, the problem may not be you; it may be your method. Returning to the ancient ways of planning and outlining may be the fix. I
Aristotle told storytellers to sketch the general outline of a story first and then fill in the scenes. All authors should read his Poetics and Rhetoric.
Why talk about outlining on a book marketing podcast? Well, good writing is key to good marketing, and bad writing can't be fixed with good marketing.
So how can you write with a better plan in mind? I asked Cameron Sutter, a YA science fiction and fantasy author and software developer. He took Brandon Sanderson's writing class and went on to create Plottr, visual outlining and series bible software for authors.
What is the first step in outlining a novel?
Thomas: Imagine you're Aristotle's student, and he tells you to plot out the beginnings of an outline. Where do you start?
Cameron: That depends on who you are. There's the discovery method, or pantsing, and there's plotting, where you have a plan beforehand. I'm not trying to convince you to be a plotter, but regardless of how you write your first draft, you'll still have to do the work of plotting, either before or after.
Thomas: For some authors, the terrible first draft ends up being their outline. They just have to figure out what outline they wrote and fix it from there. It's a discovery outline, whereas other people start with a low-resolution outline and build up from there.
Cameron: That's true. If you don't know where you're going and you write a full manuscript, you basically wrote a detailed outline, and you'll have to fix it up.
Should you start an outline with the protagonist or the setting?
Cameron: It all depends on your writing process. Creativity isn't a linear do-this-then-do-that process. I like to say it's a back-and-forth and up-and-down process. Back-and-forth means moving between the beginning and the end of the story. Up-and-down means moving between higher-level thinking and lower-level thinking, like what words you'll use.
There’s not one right place to start. It depends on where inspiration hits you. Is it a really cool character? A world? The climax of the story? That amazing moment you can't get out of your head? That said, if you're not sure where to start outlining, the main character is probably the best place to start.
Thomas: Joanna Penn would call those ideas story seeds, the core idea that inspired you to write the story in the first place. If you have a story seed, start there and build out.

Famously, C.S. Lewis had a picture in his mind of a faun, a lamppost, and some parcels on a snowy day. That iconic scene was the beginning, and he built it out wide and deep. It wasn't the first scene in the book, but I think it's still the most memorable.
He then connected it with his book Mere Christianity. Lucy is either a liar, a lunatic, or telling the truth about Narnia. That comes straight out of Mere Christianity, where Jesus is either a liar, a lunatic, or Lord. It's a straight copy and paste, but people don't realize it. Lewis was working on both things; the ideas meshed, and he built out his outline.
What do "up and down" and "back and forth" mean in outlining?

Thomas: Up is the big picture of that story seed. We have a faun in a forest. Why is he in the forest? The forest is in a land called Narnia. Why is it snowing? It's always winter and never Christmas. You start building out the world. That's what we mean by up.
Back and forth is moving within the story itself. What happens next? What happened leading up to that? A real challenge with pantsing, and with outlining too, is knowing where to start the story. At some point the action has to begin, but the characters didn't just appear. They had stories leading up to that moment.
The movie version of The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe starts a little earlier than the book. It shows the children sheltering from German bombs during the Blitz. A seven-year-old in 1960 would absolutely know what the Blitz was, because Grandma talked about it all the time. A modern kid may not, and showing it has much more power. Knowing your audience and what they need to grab their attention is also important.
Cameron: I want to push back on what you said about taking that seed and building out from there. If you're imagining concentric circles, I don't think it works that way, at least not for me.
There are probably multiple seeds for a story. You may build out in more detail from each one, but they're far apart. At some point these ideas will connect, and you have to find where. Sometimes one seed is the end of the story. Sometimes it's the character at the beginning.
That's why I don't think plotting is necessarily the “right” or best way. Even while you're plotting, you're discovery plotting. Plotters are discovery plotters. If you've already written your first draft, you'll have to go back and ask, "Where did I screw up? Where did I lose this character?" You'll have to think about the story at a higher level at that point.
What is a beat in a story?
Thomas: The core element of a plot is the beat. It's a new term in the book-writing world but an old one in screenwriting. Novel writing is increasingly influenced by screenwriting, whereas 100 years ago screenwriters were influenced by playwrights and novelists.
Cameron: There are different definitions of a beat. The most familiar one from moviemaking is when a director says, "Take a beat." That means a pause, a moment to think. What most storytellers mean by a beat is a moment or event that changes the story or a character.
Thomas: If you summarized your story, every sentence would potentially be a beat. If cutting a sentence would make the summary stop making sense, it's a beat. Beats would be a list of the core events without detail. For example, “Bilbo goes down into the cave. He's in a room with a creature. He picks up a ring, tells riddles with the creature, and escapes.”
Those are the beats, but they don't include the riddles or the dialogue. A beat is a plot-focused tool. It tracks where the plot is moving, while dialogue gives you detail about what's happening on the page.
Why do stories need a structure?

Thomas: Most books end up falling into one of the core narrative structures of Western or Eastern civilization. Many authors say, " I don't want to do that. I want to tell a unique story." But readers expect some kind of structure, and they subconsciously expect a familiar structure.
The three-act structure is core to Western civilization. The two-act, or chiastic, structure is more common in Eastern civilization. I have an episode on the chiastic structure, and I personally love it.
Dracula is almost the perfect example of chiastic story structure. Pride and Prejudice follows a chiastic structure, and so do The Cat in the Hat and Goodnight Moon. You can even work the chiastic structure into a three-act structure.
Plottr lets people pick from different structures.
Why do we need structure at all? Why can't we just let things happen?
Cameron: Whether or not writers try to follow a structure, they will. That's not to say you'll never write a unique story or include anything unexpected. These structures reflect our human nature, shaped by the culture and time period we live in. That's how we tell stories.
I lived in Chile for a couple of years, and people there told stories differently. I don't mean novel-length stories. I mean telling a friend about their day. They'd emphasize different words or tell things in a different order. At first I thought, "You de-emphasized the important part." Then I realized everybody did it. That's how they tell stories, and every culture does it slightly differently.
Readers have expectations about what will happen in a story. As a writer, you're supposed to hit and miss those expectations to your reader's delight, hitting them on purpose and missing them on purpose.
What does the three-act structure look like?
Thomas: The most familiar structure is the three-act structure, with a beginning, a middle, and an end. The first story my eldest daughter ever told when she was a toddler had a beginning, a middle, and an end, but she told it in a nonlinear way. The story went, "Mommy, Daddy, go date. Mommy, Daddy, come back. Me, cry, cry, cry."
The most emotionally potent element she wanted to convey was how sad she was.
A chiastic story has just a beginning and an end, with a peripety or a cataclysm in the middle. Western fiction commonly comes in trilogies. Eastern fiction, like anime, often comes in two parts. The first season ends with a cataclysm, and the second season ends near where the first one began.
The Bible has many chiastic structures in its narrative.
The three-act structure goes back to Aristotle's Poetics. Using a beginning, middle, and end is a Greek approach to storytelling, and it's in our DNA as a Western society.
What belongs in the beginning of a story?
Cameron: Almost all story structures and templates start with the way things were before the bad thing happens. People are going about their normal lives, and then something bad happens. That bad thing falls a little after the beginning, but the beginning is almost always normal, everyday life.
Thomas: That bad thing is the inciting incident or the call to adventure.
The hero's journey gets mapped onto the three-act structure.
There's life before: Bilbo is living happily in his house, caring for his garden.
Then comes the call to adventure: Gandalf shows up and says, "Let's go kill a dragon." Or Princess Leia says, "Help me, Obi-Wan Kenobi. You're my only hope." A farm boy hears it and decides to go rescue her. In a romance, it's meeting that cute other person.
The call to adventure is the moment you leave the boring before-time and embark on a grand journey.
Cameron: After that inciting incident, the hero usually rejects the call to adventure. They resist going or try to run away. In a horror movie, when something bad happens, they run. They're passive. They aren't actively trying to stop the disruption. They're trying to get away from it.
Thomas: In many ways, the first act is an internal battle of the protagonist wrestling with whether the story should happen. The pivot point between acts one and two is the protagonist deciding the story will happen. They’re off to rescue the princess, and there's no turning back.
Cameron: Every story is different, but there's often a moment of decision where they turn from passive to active. "I've got to face this. If I don't, there will be bad consequences," or, "I can't escape this." As the author, you must give them a reason to face it and actively pursue a resolution.
Can a story have more than one moment of decision?
Thomas: These aren't writing laws where you go to jail if you break them. You can play with these major beats.
The Matrix has three sequential moments of decision. Neo takes the phone, and he can either climb out on the ledge of the skyscraper or let himself get arrested. In the first moment, he lets the phone fall and gets arrested by Agent Smith.
In the second moment of decision, he's in the car. They open the door and say, "You can leave, but you know where this road goes, Neo." It's back to his boring life. The third is the most famous. Morpheus holds out the red pill and the blue pill, and Neo chooses the red pill.
What's normally a single point in a story happens three times, and each one ramps up the tension. That's probably why the red pill scene is so iconic. It was built to be. He said no, then he said yes but hadn't fully bought in, and now it's go or no-go.
What happens in act two of the three-act structure?
Cameron: Things get worse and worse. The hero is now actively pursuing the resolution, and you think, "It's going to get better," But it just keeps getting worse until they reach their dark moment, potentially the darkest moment of their life. That's where you flip over to act three.
Thomas: At that lowest moment, the dark night of the soul, the hero makes the next crucial decision and moves into the final act, which typically ramps up the intensity. The hero goes from loser to winner, from running away to charging.
In The Matrix, Morpheus has been captured, and the team has been killed. It's just Neo and Trinity. Neo says, "We're going back to get him." Trinity says, "That's crazy. Nobody's ever fought an agent." Neo says he'll do it.
Then comes that iconic moment. "We need guns. Lots of guns." It's not iconic because it's visually striking. You've watched plenty of visually striking movies you don't remember anything about. It's memorable because it was so core to the narrative that it had emotional punch. When the guns rush in, you think, "Yes! Go rescue Morpheus." You're invested. Neo has gone from the hunted to the hunter, fully embracing the call he answered at the beginning of act two.
What is a try-fail cycle?
Cameron: Some stories use act two to apply more and more pressure to the main character until they reach the dark night of the soul. In other stories, act two is partly training. There's a training montage, and the pressure comes from working hard to learn the skills. At some point the story breaks out of the training phase, and things get really bad. That’s what brings them to the dark night of the soul.
Thomas: This is sometimes called a try-fail cycle. You reveal the protagonist's internal character and physical abilities through the challenges you put in front of them, how they choose to overcome those challenges, and whether they succeed.
You may say, "I don't want to make my protagonist suffer." But that is a mistake. That suffering allows the later beats to hit so hard.
A good example is Inigo Montoya in The Princess Bride. "You killed my father. Prepare to die." He's constantly trying to get to the man in black and constantly failing. He's not even the protagonist, but he's the protagonist of his own story, and he's probably the most beloved character in the movie.
Finally, he hits his blackest moment at the same time the man in black hits his. That's a sign of good storytelling, because multiple characters can go through this process simultaneously.
Cameron: Multiple threads are going through the arcs.
Thomas: The man in black is being tortured to death, and Inigo is in a drunken stupor, giving up on life. He finally decides to try one more time, even if it means attacking a castle by himself. He rescues Westley, and he's still trying and failing. When he finally kills Count Rugen, you think, "Yes!" He's gone to hell and back, and his success feels earned.
How does the third act end a story?
Thomas: After the dark night of the soul comes the rising tension and then the ultimate conclusion. The good guy wins or doesn't, depending on whether it's a comedy or a tragedy. The final piece is the denouement. It can be quick or longer, but it's the resolution that lets readers sit in the happily ever after.
In a romance, act one is boy meets girl. Act two is boy loses girl. Act three is boy gets girl back.
In act three, he's decided she's the girl for him, but there are external or internal obstacles in the way. He has to fight through the jungle, so to speak, to win the beauty.
Cameron: One thing that surprised me is how short the denouement is in some older stories. I was reading Dracula, and the denouement is one sentence, maybe a page. It's basically, "We killed the beast," and that's it.
Thomas: It opens abruptly, and it ends abruptly. That book is a masterpiece. If you haven't read Dracula, the text is free, and there are many good, fully voiced audiobook versions. If you've only watched a movie version, you don't know Dracula. No character has been fictionalized on film more, and never has it been more off the mark.
Cameron: It's definitely not what you expect, but it's so good.
Thomas: It's also surprisingly Christian, which you wouldn't expect from a vampire narrative.
What are story threads?
Thomas: Let's say someone has their story seed. They've scribbled down as much as they have, zoomed out, and started writing in the major beats, like the dark night of the soul. What comes next?
Cameron: Something important to think about next is the threads of your story. A thread is anything that changes or runs throughout the story. The two most important threads are the plot and your main character's internal struggle. Threads could also be the theme, other characters, motifs, running jokes, or even physical changes.
You also have side characters and minor characters, their relationships with each other, and their relationships with the main character. Not everything needs to grow and change, but relationships often will.
You don't have to know or explain your theme. Usually, though, you set up promises at the beginning, and you want to make sure they're fulfilled at the end. Those are threads too.
I like to think about the setup and payoff of each thread individually, because each one on its own isn't that hard.
Inigo Montoya's thread isn't nearly as in-depth as the man in black's or the main plot, but he's one of the more beloved characters because he has a character arc. Readers often connect most with those minor characters.
I ask, "Does this guy have a character arc? Does this relationship have an arc? Are the promises I set up at the beginning fulfilled at the end?" That's usually my next step.
How do you keep track of setups and payoffs?
Thomas: I’ve created a setup and payoff calculator that lists all the setups in your book and their corresponding payoffs. It’s called Chekhov's Checker. It checks for foreshadowing and dropped threads and reports on how well you handled your setups and payoffs.
You don't necessarily have to tie up every thread, particularly if you're writing a series. For example, Han Solo starts as a selfish mercenary on the run from Jabba the Hutt. By the end of the movie, he's gone from selfish to selfless, but the Jabba thread hasn't been resolved yet.
There's a difference between leaving a thread dangling on purpose because you plan to pick it up in the next story and doing it by mistake. When it's a mistake, you find out about it in your two-star reviews, and you have a book out there with terrible dangling threads.
What is the core conflict of a story?
Thomas: You must also determine the story’s core conflict. A story can have more than one conflict, but every story has a primary one. It's man against man, man against himself, man against nature, man against society, man against God, or man against the creation of man. That last one is a father-against-son type of story, like Frankenstein, and it's the rarest. Most people default to man against man or man against himself.
Working in multiple conflicts can be fun. Star Wars features a surprising amount of man against nature. Every good Star Wars movie has at least one monster encounter that's separate from the overarching conflict. Why fight a monster in the garbage compactor? They could have fallen in and come right out. They could have cut that scene. Why include it? Because it's fun.
Cameron: It's a cool scene, and it shows how the different characters handle conflict. It advances character development without advancing the plot, and that's okay. Not every scene or beat has to further the plot. Your goal isn't to cut all those scenes because a scene may simply be enjoyable for your readers.
Thomas: The conflict between Han Solo and Princess Leia really develops while they're fighting this monster. Han goes from hitting her with insult after insult to being forced to work with her. "Hey, I just met you, and this is crazy, but our friend is about to die if we don't work together." I still don't like you, but we can't let Luke die.
Cameron: It's part of the try-fail cycle for sure. A try-fail cycle isn't merely a scene where they try, fail, and move on. You can add a buildup and preparation, then the try, then complications, then the failure, then the reaction to the failure.
In those moments, you see your characters react, and you heighten the sense of their failure. That garbage compactor scene is part of the rescue of the princess, and it isn't going well.
Thomas: They fail, by the way. Nothing Han, Leia, or Chewie does has any impact on whether Luke lives or dies. The droids up in the computer room save them.
Can outlining be as fun as drafting?
Thomas: Outlining can have the same joy of discovery and creation as drafting. Many people see outlining as a homework slog. "My teacher made me outline because Aristotle said to, and I hate it."
For some authors, outlining is even more fun than drafting, because this is where the true discovery of the story happens, and they can make rapid, fundamental changes much more easily.
Let's say you decide they can't fall into a trash compactor after all. If you've already written all that dialogue, you're throwing it out. That work is wasted. On the other hand, if you had only a beat in an outline, you waste far less work. You can tweak it and judge whether it fits. Once you know the big picture works, you can write the dialogue and flesh it out.
Cameron: That's the up and down. Once the higher level of the story works, you can go down the layers and start worrying about the prose, the descriptions, the dialogue, showing versus telling, that kind of stuff.
What makes a scene?
Cameron: A scene is a moment of change, an emotional change, or a change in values. By value, I mean something like safety. A character's level of safety might change because of a conversation or because a trash compactor suddenly turns on. In a romance, the level of romantic connection changes, for better or worse. A scene isn't just a place and time where things happen. There should be some kind of change.
Thomas: Scene is a term from screenwriting, and we have to be careful not to work too much screenwriting language into novel writing. It can become limiting, because there's a lot you can do with the theater of the mind that doesn't work on screen.
Cameron: The reverse is true too. Movies definitely aren't meant to work the way you'd write a book.
Thomas: Exactly. Sometimes the best books make the worst films, and sometimes terrible books turn into excellent films.
In film, a scene is often a location. The husband and wife are in the kitchen, discussing whether to flee ahead of the tornado. The language of scenes lets the director tell the location manager, "Find me a kitchen. It needs to be destructible, and we need to shoot it from these angles."
What is the scene and sequel method?
Thomas: Storytellers use the term too. Brandon Sanderson uses the scene-sequel concept, outlined by Dwight Swain's book Techniques of the Selling Writer. A scene is proactive. The character has a goal, there's conflict, and there's some kind of disaster. The sequel is the reactive piece that comes afterward. How does the character feel about what happened? Sanderson sees his stories as scene and sequel, or try and fail, as others phrase it.
You get a sequel after that trash compactor scene. Han and Leia come out still throwing insults, but now Leia is also angry at the walking carpet in front of her. Luke is toweling off his head. There are no stormtroopers and no external conflict. They're reacting to a stressful moment. It gives the audience a moment to breathe, and it resets the characters. Nothing got resolved in the compactor. In fact, the tension is higher than it's ever been.
The end of the sequel sets up the next scene. The doors open on a room full of stormtroopers, and they're off again.
Sanderson calls it a left foot, right foot approach. You're a student of Sanderson. Is this how you approach scenes?
Cameron: I've heard many people talk about it that way, and it makes sense. I don't care for the academic terms, though. It's more useful to me to say, "In a scene, something has to change." Some scenes are more active, and some are more reactive. For some people, the scene-sequel framing makes sense.
How does an outline help you fix pacing problems?
Thomas: I think of it as a pacing tool. Sometimes a book gets too intense, and readers stop reading. Other times it gets too boring or too emotionally complicated. If you have scene, scene, scene, scene, the music is always at full blast, and you lose the musicality.
This also depends on genre. Nonstop action is the pacing of a thriller, like John Wick or a Jason Bourne story. Some books never give the protagonist a toweling-off moment. He can breathe at the end of the book when he's dead, because in the next chapter, he has 24 hours to keep the nuclear bomb from going off.
The key is to know the expectations of your genre and pace on purpose. In a cozy mystery, reflection is part of the experience, because the reader is trying to solve the mystery alongside the sleuth. You have to give the reader chances to play with the clues the same way the detective does. In a thriller, you can breathe later. Suspense falls somewhere in the middle. Mystery, thriller, and suspense exist on a continuum.
To learn more about pacing, check out the following episodes:
- How to Write Cinematically with Deborah Raney
- How to Write Faster with Tricia Goyer
- Show AND Tell With Angela Hunt
- How to Write Deep Point of View with Karen Witemeyer
- Tension: The Key Ingredient for a Novel Readers Can’t Put Down
You can identify pacing issues in an outline and solve them inexpensively. Otherwise, you finish the book and think, "This is too intense. I have to write extra sequels to give readers room to breathe. How do I do that without getting boring?" If only you'd had an outline at the beginning, you could have avoided the problem.
Cameron: Those emotional ups and downs are important even in a thriller. There need to be moments where the emotions are dialed down. One of my favorite examples is Dogberry from Shakespeare’s Much Ado About Nothing.
After a really intense scene, a police officer is trying to get his men to straighten up so they can go find a miscreant. He's a funny character, and it's a goofy scene, which surprised me the first time I saw it. Later, when the intensity ramps up again, the play goes back to a funny scene with this officer.
It lets you breathe and laugh for a second. If you're always hitting the excitement and the drama, that constant high emotion exhausts you. You either put down the book or disengage. When you give readers a moment to breathe and then ramp it back up, those ups and downs make the story work.
Thomas: In The Bourne Identity, there's one breathing scene, and it's especially powerful because there are very few in the film. In every scene, Jason Bourne is trying to figure out who he is, and some random assassin shows up and tries to kill him. He fights them off and discovers he's a deadly person with skills he doesn't understand.
Finally, he escapes the town with the girl, and they're driving to the next country. The music swells. Neither Jason nor the audience knows what will happen next. The music from that scene becomes the iconic music of the whole film because it's such a powerful emotional beat. It's also the beginning of their romantic thread.
Like you said about Shakespeare, when it's rare, it's precious. If every scene is funny, any given joke lacks power. In a generally serious film, when Hulk punches Thor that one time, the whole theater loses its mind because no one expected a joke. I feel like that joke ruined Marvel, because Marvel then tried to get too funny and lost the tension.
Every child who bakes learns that more is not always better; it's about ratios. All sugar all the time isn't the way. In writing, there's no perfect balance. It depends on the reader and the genre. The important thing is to do it on purpose, and a good outline helps you see it from a bird's-eye view.
Does following a story structure make every book the same?
Cameron: One of the most surprising things to me as I've been reading classics is how different every book is. Every author has such a different style, and each is successful in their own way. I read The War of the Worlds, and it was so different from Dracula, not just in genre but in writing style, description, and how much they showed versus told.
It's almost like getting a glimpse into the writer's brain. I bring this up because even though we've talked about structure and how to plot a book, don't let that eclipse your story. The way you think about a story, tell it to people, and write it out is important and unique to you. You can be successful with a different book than the guy next to you.
Thomas: That's Einstein's mountain of simplicity. You start with simplicity, then you climb the mountain of complexity, and once you cross it, you get to simple. Your goal with an outline and with tools like beats, pacing, and conflict is to reach that simple, core version of your approach to writing.

You do have to cross that mountain of complexity, though. You need to understand the rules so you can break them on purpose. The klutz breaks the rules without knowing it, and that's slop, or slush, as older generations called it. A master breaks the rules with intention. "We won't have one moment of decision. We'll have three, and each will introduce a different character." The first introduces Agent Smith, the second Trinity, and the third Morpheus.
When you know the rules well enough, you can say, "I know gravity normally pulls things down, but air pressure can push things up. With enough speed and the correct wing shape, I can make this story fly." You aren't breaking the law of gravity. You've combined it with other laws, like aerodynamics, which keep something heavier than air in the sky.
What is Plottr?

Thomas: You make software that helps people pull all these pieces together. It doesn't use AI at all. It's good old-fashioned software, but it isn't a word processor.
Cameron: Plottr is two things. It's a visual way to see the high level of your story, and it's your series bible. It isn't where you write your story. Think of sticky notes on a wall or index cards. Lines run horizontally, and those are the threads of your story. The plot is one, and your character's change is another.
Columns run vertically, and those are the scenes or chapters. Digital sticky notes sit at each intersection, so you can see what each character is doing in each chapter and the threads running throughout your story.
Being able to see it changes the game. Whether you write the first draft first or plan beforehand, you still have to think about the story at that high level. You can see it instead of trying to keep 50,000 or 100,000 words of details organized in your head. When you can see it visually, you can drag and drop and say, "This would make a much bigger impact on my reader if I moved this part over here and revealed this attribute of the character."
How does the Plottr timeline work?
Thomas: It also has a timeline tool, which was the first feature I found really interesting. Say you have three characters, the guy, the girl, and the rival. You can map who's in what town when and make sure nobody's teleporting.
Cameron: It also helps you spot plot holes or the sagging middle. The timeline is that visual way of seeing it.
Thomas: It can also zoom out to something like the history of the elves in Middle-earth. Then the dwarves invaded, and so on. It doesn't have to be a scene-by-scene timeline.
Cameron: Many people think a timeline means dates and times, but I think of it as the story's timeline, where each column is a scene or chapter. You can rename the columns to be years or whatever you want. If you want to map out the elves' whole history, you can do that too. Then it becomes a series bible for your worldbuilding, with all your character information and backstory.
Thomas: If you made a timeline for the TV show 24, the whole thing would happen inside one day. Sometimes it's just about getting the linear element of what happens when and what happens next.
Can nonlinear storytellers use Plottr?
Cameron: Definitely. Plottr is meant to be flexible. You can color one of the scene cards and say, "This one is in the past." You could name a column with a date or time. You could also make one of the horizontal lines a different timeline, so two timelines run in parallel.
Can Plottr handle branching plots?
Thomas: Say I want to write a choose-your-own-adventure book. If he opens the door, turn to page 23. If he climbs in the window, turn to page 45. Is that built in?
Cameron: No, it isn't. We need more reader-directed storytelling, though. "Choose your own adventure" is trademarked. I could see that being really fun.
Many people use Plottr for video games, which sometimes have branching logic, or for Dungeons & Dragons campaigns. There are ways to use it effectively for branching logic without the feature, but that's not its main purpose.
Does Plottr replace Scrivener?
Thomas: It's interactive. I can grab a scene and move it from one chapter to another. Many people hear us say "index cards" and think of Scrivener. They wonder whether they'd still need Plottr.
Cameron: I still use Scrivener. Plottr comes before and after Scrivener. It helps you plot in a more visual way and keep your information straight for your whole series, including characters, worldbuilding, and backstory. Then you export your Plottr project to Scrivener; your corkboard is already set up, and you write the story there.
Meanwhile, you keep Plottr open in another window as your source of truth. When you come up with new characters, you put them in Plottr. When you finish in Scrivener, things have almost certainly changed, so you readjust things in Plottr. Then, within that same project, you can work on book two with all your characters still there.
With Scrivener, you'd have to copy and paste your characters. Plottr becomes the home base for your writing process.
Thomas: That makes it agnostic about which writing tool you use, which matters because we're in a renaissance right now. Twenty years ago, everyone used Microsoft Word because it was really the only option. Now, I find out about a cool new word processor every few weeks, each tailored to a certain kind of writer or writing.
When everybody used the same software for memos, letters, novels, and flyers, it became difficult to use. You wade through the jungle of features you don't need to find the ones you do, and you end up using basically none of them. Most people using Word just use spell check, highlighting, and bold.
Since Plottr isn't a word processor, you can send your work back and forth with any of those other tools.
Cameron: You can keep using the tool you love. You don't have to give it up or learn something new. Plottr gives you superpowers on top of it.
Should discovery writers try outlining?
Thomas: I hope you give outlining a try. Most of you probably started with the terrible-first-draft approach, and that may be where you end up. That's okay, because it's the better approach for many people. It may not be the better approach for you, though.
I've met many authors who wrongly assumed they were outliners and turned out to be discovery writers the whole time, or vice versa. The only way to know is to try. You can use the software either way, so Cameron is betting on both horses.
Many authors complete our course The Five-Year Plan, and try discovery writing and then go back to outlining. They've grown. Writing a story without a safety net changed them and made them more mature authors.
If you've always used a sword, try a spear. When you pick up a sword again, you'll understand the other guy with the spear.

