For Week Ending November 13, 2026

This week, Amazon Ads quietly erases your KENP royalty estimates, ChatGPT’s new Wallet lets AI agents buy books straight from authors. Plus, a Microsoft outage that locked writers out of their manuscripts, and took the heat off of vellum. But first, we have a new host today. Jonathan is under the weather, so professional editor Matthew Bowman is subbing in.

Publishing News

The Dead Guys Pay the Bills: Inside HarperCollins' "Comeback" Quarter

According to News Corp's SEC filing, HarperCollins wants you to see a comeback. News Corp's quarterly earnings release on file with the SEC shows book revenue up 9% to $582 million for the quarter ending September 30. Profit, measured as Segment EBITDA, jumped 29% to $75 million. CEO Robert Thomson told analysts margins climbed to 12.9% from 10.9%.

Big numbers. Now read the fine print.

The Comeback That Isn't

HarperCollins ate a $13 million loss last year when book wholesaler Baker & Taylor went under. That loss disappeared this year, and its absence powers much of the 29% jump.

Add the $13 million back and last year's profit lands at $71 million. HarperCollins grew underlying profit by $4 million, not $17 million.

Our math flips the margin story. Without the write-off, HarperCollins kept 13.3 cents of every dollar last year. This year it kept 12.9 cents.

Costs grew right alongside sales. CFO Lavanya Chandrashekar blamed higher royalties, manufacturing and marketing for new releases, and she warned analysts to expect more of the same next quarter.

HarperCollins earned $81 million in this same quarter 2 years ago. It still hasn't climbed back.

Where the Money Actually Comes From

Older books generated 66% of HarperCollins' consumer revenue this quarter, up from 65% last year. Two of every 3 dollars came from the backlist.

And look at who sits on that backlist:

J.R.R. Tolkien. HarperCollins controls the global English-language rights to The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings after News Corp bought Houghton Mifflin Harcourt's trade division in 2021.

C.S. Lewis. HarperCollins signed on as Lewis's primary English-language publisher worldwide back in 2001. Narnia lives there.

Agatha Christie. Poirot and Miss Marple belong to the HarperCollins catalog.

George Orwell. The same 2021 deal brought 1984 and Animal Farm to HarperCollins in the US.

News Corp doesn't break out which backlist titles earned what. But nobody should wonder which names keep the lights on at the second-largest consumer publisher on Earth.

Edit the Classics, Then Cash In on Them

Watch what HarperCollins does with that inheritance.

2023: The Sunday Telegraph revealed that HarperCollins reworked or cut passages in new editions of Christie's Poirot and Marple mysteries. Insiders told the paper the company uses sensitivity readers.

September 2026: HarperCollins' William Morrow imprint released Lucy Foley's Murder at the Grand Alpine Hotel, the first authorized Miss Marple novel in 50 years. Thomson singled it out on the earnings call as one of the quarter's hits.

February 2027: Greta Gerwig's Narnia: The Magician's Nephew opens in theaters February 12 and streams on Netflix April 2. Thomson told analysts he expects the film to boost HarperCollins' promotion of the books. HarperCollins already lists a 7-book Narnia movie tie-in box set for November 24.

HarperCollins scrubbed Christie's prose 3 years ago. This month it paraded her detective in front of Wall Street. The house needs the founders more than the founders need the house.

The AI Check in the Mail

Thomson also told analysts he expects HarperCollins to collect its first payment from the $1.5 billion Anthropic copyright settlement "in the near term." He calls News Corp's AI strategy "woo and sue." The house cuts licensing deals with the AI companies that pay and takes the rest to court. Authors with books in that settlement should watch for the same money.

Audio Keeps Climbing

Audiobook revenue rose 13%. Thomson credited HarperCollins' global partnership with Spotify.

Ann Patchett's Whistler drove the audio growth on both Spotify and Audible, according to the CFO.

Overall digital sales rose 6% and held steady at 23% of consumer revenue.

What This Means for Authors

  • Build a backlist, not a launch. The second-largest publisher in the world makes 2 of every 3 dollars from old books. Write series. Keep your rights. Every title should earn for decades.
  • Classic storytelling sells. HarperCollins chose to revive Miss Marple, not reinvent her, and reviewers praised the book for staying true to Christie's era. Readers want the real thing.
  • Mark February on your calendar. Christian fantasy and portal fantasy authors should line up ads, sales and new releases for the Narnia window from February 12 through Netflix's April 2 launch.
  • Guard your audio rights. A 13% audiobook jump tells you those rights still carry real money at the negotiating table.
  • Read past the headline. A 29% "surge" built on a missing write-off tells you to check the math before you believe any publisher's victory lap.
  • News Corp gave no numbers for Christian publishing, so this report says nothing new about Thomas Nelson or Zondervan.

Sources:

Commentary

Matthew: Looks like it's necro billing here. Dead guys are paying the bills. HarperCollins had a comeback quarter, but it's not really the comeback they want everyone to believe.

Thomas: All the top-line numbers make it look like a good quarter, but they're comparing against a year ago, when we were covering the Baker & Taylor drama and publishers had to take a big write-off. Compare against a black swan bad quarter and you get one good quarter.

The dirty little secret is that the money powering HarperCollins comes from four authors you may have heard of: J.R.R. Tolkien, C.S. Lewis, Agatha Christie, and George Orwell. Those are their bestselling books.

Some of the books the pub board is publishing make money, but many of them lose money. What keeps these companies profitable is their backlist.

George Orwell in particular has had an amazing run. He's become very popular in recent years. In 2020 and 2021, his book 1984 was at the top of the charts, often ranking in the top 10 books, period. That's great for a company like HarperCollins, because a book like that has no editorial costs and no cover costs. It's just printing and distribution.

So always take publishing financial statements with a grain of salt, and always adjust for inflation. These companies have a fiduciary duty to make the numbers look as good as they can, but that doesn't mean the numbers are actually good.

HarperCollins Keeps 13 Cents of Every Book Dollar

According to the News Corp fiscal Q1 2027 release, HarperCollins Book Publishing revenue rose 9% to $582 million in the quarter ended September 30, while Segment EBITDA rose 29% to $75 million. That works out to an EBITDA margin of 12.9%, up from 10.9% a year earlier. Publishers Weekly reported the EBITDA figure as $79 million, but the official release, earnings call, and investor materials all show $75 million.

What the Numbers Actually Mean

News Corp does not disclose a true net profit or net income number for the HarperCollins segment. The closest measure is Segment EBITDA, which is earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortization. In plain terms, of every dollar of book revenue that came in, HarperCollins kept roughly 13 cents as EBITDA. The other 87 cents covered the costs of running the business: author royalties, manufacturing, marketing, salaries, and overhead. CFO Lavanya Chandrashekar said on the earnings call that costs rose 7% this quarter, driven by higher royalties, manufacturing, and marketing tied to new frontlist releases. The margin expansion was helped by the absence of last year's $13 million write-off related to the Baker & Taylor collapse. No paper, freight, or returns figures were broken out beyond the general manufacturing note, and no AI licensing income was recognized in the quarter.

Genre Signals

The company attributed the results to strength in general trade and children's publishing. Named titles that performed well included Ann Patchett's Whistler, Daniel Silva's Ransom, and R.F. Kuang's Taipei Story. CEO Robert Thomson also highlighted a Lucy Foley novel that brings back Agatha Christie's Miss Marple. Digital sales rose 6%, driven by a 13% increase in audiobook revenue that Thomson tied to the Spotify partnership and efforts to make audio a higher-yielding format. Backlist accounted for 66% of consumer revenue, up from 65%. Digital remained 23% of consumer revenue. No breakout was given for Christian publishing (Thomas Nelson or Zondervan), romance or romantasy, or specific franchises. The audiobook growth was not broken down by genre.

Why Authors Care

A 12.9% EBITDA margin means the house is keeping more of each dollar than last year, but the bulk of the profit still sits in backlist titles that have already earned their advances.

Children's and general trade are the categories News Corp called out. That is where demand showed up in this quarter, not a broad green light for every genre.

The 13% audiobook jump, credited to Spotify, is a concrete signal that audio rights still have negotiating value, especially for titles that can perform on streaming platforms.

Indie authors in children's, general trade, or thriller categories can see that consumer demand is present. The backlist weighting also shows that established titles continue to generate the majority of the revenue a large publisher keeps.

No Christian publishing numbers were disclosed, so there is no new signal on acquisition volume or priority for that market from this report.

Sources:

Novel Marketing Conference

The Novel Marketing Conference is hands-on book marketing for authors who want to sell more books while spending less time on marketing. It is not a typical writers conference. January 22–23, 2027 at the Fickett Center in Austin. Leave with a written plan, a writers group of seven similar authors, and interactive workshops.

There is one rare Super Ticket left, which includes the Thursday Advertising Workshop. You’ll get three full days of training. Only 8 Standard Tickets remain at NovelMarketingConference.com.

Amazon Ads Drops Estimated KENP Royalties From Author Reports

According to PPC Land, Amazon Ads updated its Support Center page on Kindle Edition Normalized Pages (KENP) metrics on November 11, 2026, to state that “Estimated KENP royalties metrics are no longer available in Reporting.” Authors who use Amazon Ads on KDP titles enrolled in what Amazon’s publishing pages now call Kindle+ no longer see an estimate of the money those ad-attributed page reads produced.

What Happened

The old metric, added for US Sponsored Products advertisers in early November 2020 and later extended to other countries, multiplied the day’s ad-attributed KENP by that day’s published rate (or the prior month’s rate when the current one was not yet out). Roger Packer covered the original launch. That page-based estimate is gone. The page now describes estimated royalties calculated for “qualified borrows”: times a Kindle Unlimited / Kindle+ reader downloaded a book and read enough pages to qualify for a royalty payment. Amazon does not state how many pages that takes.

Authors still see KENP read (the estimated number of pages read that Amazon attributes to an ad interaction, up to 14 days after a click, with offline devices lagging up to a week). They also see the count of qualified borrows and the new estimated royalties figure attached to those borrows. The metrics are split by clicks versus views and by promoted books versus halo books, and they appear across six campaign types, including DVA+, according to the Paid Media News tracker. A converted-currency version is available. Amazon notes that actual royalties may differ and points authors to their KDP reports.

KDP’s own Royalties in Kindle+ page still describes payment as a share of the monthly Global Fund based on first-time pages read or listened, measured in KENP. “You’re paid for the first time a subscriber reads or listens to a given page in your book.” No borrow threshold appears. The ads console’s “qualified borrow” language therefore does not match the published KDP payout rule. Whether the threshold is only an internal modeling choice for the ad estimate, or a signal that Kindle+ payment rules are changing, is unconfirmed. Amazon has not said the payout basis is moving from per page to per borrow.

The KDP Advertising for KDP books help page continues to note the difference between KDP reports (all activity) and Amazon Ads reports (ad-attributed activity only, with delays). No date or reason for the royalty-estimate removal is given on the ads page.

Why Authors Care

Ad tracking for page-read income is less transparent. Readers who open a book but do not reach the undefined qualification threshold can disappear from the royalty estimate even though KDP still pays on the pages they read.

The gap hits hardest for authors in Kindle+ with long books or series read-through, whose bid and pause decisions rely on page-read ROI rather than sales-only ACoS.

Export and save historical ad reports now, before further reporting migrations remove older data.

Compare the remaining ad-attributed KENP read and qualified-borrow figures against KDP’s actual page-read reports in a spreadsheet. Track series read-through yourself.

Do not pause or cut campaigns solely because the estimated royalty number drops. The page-read money may still be there.

Watch the next KDP Select Global Fund announcement and any KDP help-page language changes for signs that the actual payment rule is shifting. No such change has been announced.

No specific author-forum, Reddit r/selfpublish, Facebook ad-group, Written Word Media, Kindlepreneur, or Selling for Authors reaction to this particular Ads console change was located as of November 13. The larger recent KENP and estimator drops authors discussed after October 21 were tied to the Kindle+ reporting migration that separated listened pages and removed certain Audible Plus virtual-voice activity from KENP views.

Sources:

Commentary

Thomas: Everyone was complaining that the estimates were really off. They seemed really low, and everyone was losing their minds. Remember we told you last week, "Don't worry, this is just the reporting. Don't freak out until your actual check or direct deposit from Amazon is wrong."

Well, instead of fixing the reporting, Amazon got rid of the reporting. Now there's no chart to freak out about.

The problem is that this was a very useful chart for making real-time marketing decisions. Many authors use it to guide their ads and their promotion in other places. Without good real-time data, it's harder to make your ads work.

My hope is that they bring it back. If not, this is a real loss for the author community and a real knock against Kindle+. I think many authors would rather go back to Kindle Unlimited with estimated sales than have Kindle+, where they lose out if they don't have audiobooks. Remember, some of the Kindle+ pot goes toward audiobooks.

Authors with good penetration in the audiobook market get extra bites at the apple. If you don't have audiobooks, you don't get those bites.

There are many ebook-only, KU-focused authors running the 20 Books to 50K strategy of carpet bombing their sub-sub-subgenre with books. You write them fast and put them in a series. The only money you make is from the ebook. The paperback is just for funsies. Some of these authors don't even order their own paper books.

It's all ebooks all the time, and that strategy is getting nerfed by Amazon a little in the medium term. If you're using ads, it's getting nuked in the near term.

Don’t panic. You’re only losing the real-time reporting, and I think it's only for a short period. I suspect they see that something is wrong, and until they can show you the correct numbers, they don't want to show you any numbers at all. From a strategic perspective, it's better to have no data than wrong data. Having confidence in the wrong numbers is worse than being honest with yourself that you don't know what the numbers are.

Matthew: The world moves so fast right now that it's tempting to move faster to keep up with everything. Moving fast on a gut feeling might work, or it might not. But when you've got uncertainties like this, it's usually best to wait, especially when it's something you can't control anyway.

So calm down and write more books.

Thomas: You will still get the data. You'll just get it slower. It's never a mistake to put your head down and work on your marketing.

But it is rough if you're spending money on ads every day. You need good analytics, so hopefully they turn that back on.

Diderot Marketing Opportunity: Audible Hands 15,000 Teens Free Premium Subscriptions

According to Publishers Weekly and Audible’s own newsroom, Audible launched Imagine Louder on October 15. The program partners with seven nonprofits in the U.S., U.K., and Mexico to give free six-month Audible Premium memberships to 15,000 young people over three years. Each membership includes unlimited listening to thousands of titles in the included catalog—the all-you-can-listen Plus Catalog—plus one credit per month for any title in the full Audible catalog. Audible says that comes to more than 180,000 hours of audio per membership. A parent or guardian manages the account and adds titles to a kid’s profile.

What Happened

The seven partners are Girl Rising in Mexico; DreamYard in the Bronx, Flockworks on California’s rural Mendocino Coast, and Life Anew Restorative Justice in Austin in the U.S.; and VICTA, Be Free Campaign, and Exodus Youth Worx UK in the United Kingdom. Audible asked each nonprofit to explain how it would weave the memberships into existing programs rather than handing them out cold. The groups use the listening for poetry workshops, radio plays, book clubs for visually impaired youth, mental-health conversations, and community sessions. Audible also provides grant money so the nonprofits can build the work in. The program targets ages 12 to 18; Publishers Weekly quotes Aisha Glover of Audible’s Global Center for Urban Innovation calling it primarily teen-based, with some partners working with young adults up to 22.

Audible piloted the approach for six months. In the U.S. pilot with Reading Partners, 77 percent of caregivers rated their child engaged or very engaged. In the U.K. pilot with the National Literacy Trust, 100 percent of teachers said the program encouraged students to listen to more audiobooks. In Mexico with Girl Rising, 95 percent of participants agreed that stories are a tool for self-expression and personal development. Audible plans to expand to more countries once it has more data on age groups and content.

Why Authors Care

Fifteen thousand young people over three years is small next to Audible’s overall size. The longer-term win is growing future readers and listeners in communities that have had less access. A teen who falls for book one of a series inside the Plus Catalog, or spends a credit on it, becomes a full-series buyer once the free months end.

We covered the Diderot Effect on Novel Marketing episode 522 on November 4. Once someone owns one piece of a matching set, they want the whole set. That is why we tell authors to put a picture of the complete series in the back of every book, including the one the reader is holding. The same logic applies here.

Practical moves for authors of YA, middle grade, and series fiction:

Have audiobooks at all, and make book one easy to find.

Consider putting a series starter in the Audible Plus Catalog if that is an option for you. Under the new royalty model that opened on ACX in May 2026, rights holders can opt titles in to be considered for the all-you-can-listen catalog. Audible selects which titles enter. Listening royalties come from the membership pool based on engagement, not a fixed credit amount. Exact rates, selection criteria, and how long a title stays in the catalog are not fully public, so treat the opt-in as a consideration, not a guarantee.

At the end of each audiobook, state the series order and that the complete set is available—the audio version of the back-of-book collection picture.

Use consistent series branding on audiobook covers so the set looks like a set.

Sources:

Commentary

Thomas: My recent episode on the Diderot Effect talked about how once people start a collection, they want to continue it. Audible is giving you a huge Diderot marketing opportunity.

Matthew: The only wrinkle is that a parent or guardian manages the account and adds the titles. So if you're marketing to this, you're still marketing somewhat to the parents. But it's good to get your books in front of the kids.

Thomas: And if they start listening to your series, they'll want to continue.

This is also the latest volley in the audiobook wars. It shows you where Audible sees that it's weak. Spotify tends to be very popular with young people, and Audible is realizing, "Oh no, if the next generation starts its audiobook listening on Spotify, they'll never leave and switch over to Audible."

Their thinking is, "Sure, we're super popular with old people like millennials and Gen Xers and whatever's older than Gen X. But these Gen Z and Gen Alpha kids are listening to Spotify all the time, and they're not even trying Audible." That's a long-term disadvantage.

So they're trying this. It's a kind of weather balloon. If it works, they may roll it out with school districts, giving out more of these free subscriptions to get young people listening to audiobooks.

A key moment in my life came when I had a college assignment to read a book that was on Audible. I had already bought it at the university bookstore, but I spent my own Audible credit on the audiobook and listened to it. It was one of the first times I read ahead in class.

I'd never read ahead in my life. I barely managed to finish the assignment by the time class was done. But I enjoyed the book, so I kept listening to the whole thing, and I had a much better discussion and debate with the professor than I normally did. I was like, "Wow."

It was a huge breakthrough for me.

The war between Audible and Spotify is very much like the war between the Romans and the Persians. Each has its own separate power source that doesn't threaten the other. Amazon has a million ways to make money outside of audiobooks, and Spotify makes most of its money from music. But they're both fighting over Armenia, which is audiobook land.

Matthew: That's what makes this a good analogy and not just shoehorning in Rome. They're fighting over that middle area and trying to get the overlaps.

Frankly, Audible hasn't done much that's interesting in the audiobook wars. Mostly it's been cosmetic, like their points program. This is the first time I've seen anything from Audible that looks like it could have an effect.

Like you said, it's a trial balloon.

Thomas: But these are parents with money to spend on credits. If you do a good job targeting the parents who are selected, though I'm not sure how you'd do that, or if you target parents generally and create audiobook content for children, there are real opportunities here.

My wife and I spend a surprising amount of money on audio content for our children. We have Spotify Premium, and I curate a playlist of stories there that my littler ones listen to at nighttime. We also have an Adventures in Odyssey subscription from Focus on the Family. It's one of the only entertainment subscriptions we have as a family.

My oldest listens to Adventures in Odyssey every night. She would listen all day long if she could.

Publishing Staff Median Pay Drops

According to Publishers Weekly’s 2026 Salary and Jobs Report, published November 6, median pay among respondents fell to $78,000 from $80,000 the prior year while management salaries rose about 8%. Editorial, operations, and sales/marketing saw little change. The same survey found 40% of respondents expect to remain in the same job two years from now, citing limited advancement as a main complaint.

What Happened

Respondents reported a median salary of $78,000, down from the $80,000 median in the 2025 report. Men in the sample averaged $89,000, down from $97,000; women averaged $79,000, up slightly from $78,500. Those with six years or less experience averaged $57,100, up from $56,000. Eighty percent of respondents received a raise, averaging 3%.

Eighty percent of respondents were female. Among those with six years or less experience, 24% identified as male (16%) or non-binary (8%), up from 20% the year before. The share of white respondents rose to 79% from 76%. Nonwhite respondents with six years or less experience reached 65%, compared with 61% in 2024. PW noted that the earlier decline in new BIPOC employees echoed prior concerns that pushback against DEI could slow hiring.

Sixty percent said they were very satisfied with their jobs. Sixty-eight percent expected to still be at the same company in two years, either in the same role or higher. The 40% who expected to remain in the same job pointed to scarce promotion opportunities. Among those considering leaving publishing, only 29% reported being happy in their current role.

On artificial intelligence, 73% said their company uses AI in some form, most often for market research. Seventy-seven percent held a negative view of the technology. The leading concern was the risk of helping publish a book substantially written by AI. One respondent called a mandatory AI goal “inane and insulting.” A minority voice said the industry must adapt to survive.

The published report does not state the exact number of respondents or detailed methodology. The prior year’s survey drew 726 responses. Broader Bureau of Labor Statistics data show seasonally adjusted employment in publishing industries (except internet) at 880,000 in October 2026, down from 890,000 in July.

Why Authors Care

Limited advancement and flat pay in editorial and marketing roles increase the odds of editor and publicist turnover. Books can be orphaned when the person who acquired or championed them leaves.

A 3% average raise against a lower median leaves more staff under financial pressure. That pressure can translate into slower response times, thinner developmental editing, or reduced marketing support for midlist titles.

High AI skepticism inside houses does not stop companies from testing the tools. Authors should ask agents and editors explicitly how any AI use will be disclosed and whether it affects rights, royalties, or credit.

Indie and hybrid routes bypass the internal ladder entirely. Authors who control their own production, marketing, and direct sales avoid waiting on understaffed departments whose primary complaint is the lack of promotion paths.

Practical step this week: when pitching or following up, ask about the current editor’s tenure and the house’s recent turnover in your genre. A short conversation about staffing stability is cheaper than discovering your book has no champion six months after acquisition.

Sources:

Commentary

Thomas: I wonder if this is a result of AI. AI lets people in management roles do more, because they can delegate tasks to agents if they're AI fluent. I'm not sure how many people in traditional publishing are AI fluent. If you’d ask, "Which AI harness do you use?" they say, "What's a harness? What's a markdown file?" Most of them don't know.

But some do. They could have a whole team of Grok Bots that efficiently increase the amount of work they can do, which potentially makes them actually worth that 8% raise.

So, this may not be a boss-sticking-it-to-the-little-guy story, but it may be. I know there's a lot of AI penetration behind the scenes in trad pub. Not on the editorial side, but on the operations side. If you're able to get more work done, you can get more pay. That's the positive way to view it.

The negative way, is that managers are giving themselves raises and cutting the wages of the people doing the actual work. If that's what's happening, it won't go well for them, because more and more people are finding there's more money in the indie world.

That same person working for $78,000 at a New York firm and paying New York prices for rent and groceries could easily live anywhere else in the country, work the freelance market, make the same or more money, and have far lower expenses. The market will balance it out eventually.

Matthew: As a freelance editor, I always pay attention to the yearly surveys from the Editorial Freelancers Association on the median charge for different editorial services, mostly so I can undercut them.

In years of following those surveys, this last year I saw a drop almost cleanly across the board in pricing on editorial services, at least the ones I pay attention to. They cover a lot of editing I don't do.

You can look at that two ways. Either they're feeling the pressure from AI tools, especially the copy editors, because AI can copy edit almost as well as the average good copy editor and much faster. Or they're realizing they won't get as many hiring opportunities from big publishers, so they're aiming more at indies and dropping their prices to be a little less New York.

Thomas: Are those prices by the word?

Matthew: They're priced by the word.

Thomas: Then another way to interpret the numbers is that as more editors embrace AI, they can edit a chapter in 30 minutes instead of an hour with the same quality. They have the same judgment they had before. They give the client the same level of output. But they do it in half the time. Because of that, they can charge less and make more money, since they're paid by the project.

Jonathan is seeing this as he's launched a new audiobook production business with music, sound effects, and a full cast. It's an amazing experience, and he can be incredibly cost competitive because he uses AI to reduce the cost of putting the sound effects into the script.

It's still his judgment. It's still a human verifying everything. But these new tools make him more efficient, so costs come down. We may be seeing the same thing on the editorial side.

So this may actually mean more money for editors at a lower rate for authors, which seems like a win-win to me.

Matthew: I've been seeing that same thing, and I've been recommending it.

Personally, I have a rule that if I get someone's manuscript, it does not touch any AI without the express permission of the author. That meant I had to bend over backward to disable Copilot when I was using Word, because they make that hard.

I've only had two authors who said, "Yes, please run my manuscript through an AI." Both times I used the Patron Toolbox to get a different perspective. Some of what came back was garbage. The stuff I took from it was stuff I would have noticed anyway. I just got there faster.

The example I always use lately is that AI is very good at being average fast. It smooths out your lowest moments. It's like rolling a die that never lands on one. It doesn't make you any better at the job, but your average output goes up.

That's a great way to use the tool as an author, an editor, or a marketer. But you have to know how to do the job in the first place.

Thomas: Many editors use the Patron Toolbox because there's no training on the tool. It's a higher level of security than you get using Codex or Claude, because it runs through the API. It also doesn't touch the document. It gives you a report, and you as the editor choose what goes in and what doesn't.

It's still your judgment at the end, which means even the Pope would approve. The official papal position on AI is that it's a useful tool, but not to the degree that it undermines human judgment. His encyclical is really big on human judgment.

New Patron Tool: Chekhov Checker

We just shipped Chekhov's Checker to the Patron Toolbox. It reads a finished novel and shows you the setups that never pay off, the twists that arrive with nothing earlier to earn them, and the promises left hanging. For each missing setup it suggests a place you could plant it.

You can ask follow-up questions or push back. Show it a passage it missed and it takes another look, but it will not change its answer just to please you.

It works for standalone novels and series books. Tell it where the book sits in the series and it leaves alone the threads you are saving for later. It only sees the book you upload, so it cannot confirm a setup planted in an earlier volume. Mystery and fantasy writers can check whether clues play fair and whether magic or technology that saves the day was set up first. Name up to five twists or payoffs you want checked first.

We built it for novels. It does not hunt timeline slips, continuity errors, or typos, and it does not rewrite the book. An AI can still misread a scene or miss a faint hint, so weigh every finding against your own pages.

Your manuscript stays private. We never store or view it, and the AI companies do not train on it.

It is included with a Novel Marketing Patreon membership of $10 a month or more and gives you access to all 95 tools in the Patron Toolbox. A full novel uses more of the monthly allowance than a short task, and each chat question counts too.

Try Chekhov's Checker and catch the dangling promises before a reader writes the review.

Commentary

Thomas: Chekov’s Checker is a foreshadowing, setup, and payoff checker. It checks for guns left on the mantelpiece, which is why we call it the Chekhov Checker.

Thomas: It also checks for reveals that had no foreshadowing, and it suggests how you could foreshadow them earlier in the story. You're welcome to completely disregard those suggestions. Don't take them as my official position on how to fix your book. They're just to get the gears turning.

I suspect it will help with all fiction, but it'll be particularly helpful for anyone writing mysteries. I built in special features so that if it detects you're writing a mystery, it adjusts its report to help you make sure you have a good mystery.

It's part of the $10.00-a-month subscription, which gives you access to all 95 Patron Toolbox tools. The number is creeping closer and closer to 100. It's getting out of hand.

Commenter Question: Are you using these tools for developmental editing only?

Matthew: We have a question directed at me in the chat from Rage in the Cage: "Are you using this for all editing or just developmental?"

I don't do copy editing anymore. There are so many tools out there that you'll get better value doing copy editing yourself with tools and then having someone with an English degree check it.

For developmental, yes, the tools are very useful when the author gives me permission. I specify that because some trolls claim I do otherwise, and I don't. They can't find my authors to speak out against me, because I protect my clients' identities.

Thomas: If you're a good editor, you're not paid for editing, because editing is not that valuable. What's valuable is taste and judgment. That's what a good editor is paid for.

Matthew: I'm paid for my opinion. That's it. So I'll use those tools for developmental edits.

I haven't found a reliable tool for line editing, so every bit of that has been me so far. I haven't found an AI that can statistically generate a better sentence faster than I can, because I still have to go back and edit the thing I'm supposed to be editing in the first place. So why bother?

Publishing Stopped Writing for Boys Then Boys Stopped Reading

According to Afoma Umesi of Reading Middle Grade, parents and teachers kept asking Afoma Umesi one question: "Do you have anything for boys?" She rolled her eyes at first. Then she started counting.

Umesi built a database of 444 middle-grade novels that U.S. traditional publishers released in 2026, books for kids roughly 8 to 12. She published her boy-book count on Substack on September 30. The Atlantic picked up the story on November 5, and its post pulled more than 2 million views on X. When The Atlantic notices a boy problem, you know the problem got big.

The Count

  • 253 books star a girl. 118 star a boy. That works out to 2.14 girls for every boy.
  • 67 books split the lead, 3 star nonbinary characters, and 4 have no gendered lead.
  • Contemporary realistic fiction runs 3.62 to 1.
  • Mystery for ages 10 and up runs 3.13 to 1.
  • Fantasy comes closest at 1.89 to 1.
  • Paranormal stands alone as the one genre where boys outnumber girls.

Umesi calls her count substantial, not exhaustive. She also wrote that it "almost feels like we're at the point of overcorrection."

Who Picks the Books

Women run the room. The Lee & Low 2023 Diversity Baseline Survey found cis women hold 71.3% of jobs across publishing houses, review journals and literary agencies. Cis men hold 20.6%. Lee & Low saw this coming. Its 2015 survey analysis said those numbers "may help explain" why children's publishing seems to skew toward girls.

The author pool tilts the same way, and authors write what they know. Middle-grade author Sam Subity analyzed about 500 books from 2024. Male authors put a boy at the center of about 2 out of 3 books. Female authors put a boy at the center of about 1 in 4.

Kwame Alexander hit that wall himself. Publishers doubted boys would read poetry or girls would read a sports book when he shopped The Crossover. The book went on to win the 2015 Newbery Medal. Alexander told The Atlantic that women dominate the middle-grade author pool, that publishers treat girls as the proven, lower-risk audience, and that the field needs to mentor more men into the job.

Now look at the genre with the worst gap. One middle-grade author recalled on the From the Mixed-Up Files blog that a veteran editor waved off boy-led realistic manuscripts with a blunt rule: middle-grade boys don't read realistic fiction. Editors stop buying the books. The shelf empties. Boys stop browsing it. Then the sales data "proves" the editor right.

The Boys Fall Behind

Nobody has proven that protagonist gender causes the reading gap. The gap itself, though, looks brutal.

Boys score lower than girls in reading in nearly every U.S. school district and at every tested grade, according to Stanford's Educational Opportunity Project under Professor Sean Reardon.

Boys trail by about three-quarters of a grade level in 4th grade and by roughly a full year in 12th.

A Stanford kindergarten study found the literacy gap at kindergarten runs about half the size of the gap in grades 3 through 8. The gap roughly doubles on the road into the middle-grade years.

One bright spot: the 2025 NAEP Long-Term Trend test showed 9-year-old boys tying girls for the first time in its 50-year history. Researcher Megan Kuhfeld warned at the Fordham Institute that no other national data backs it up. Main NAEP showed the gap widening between 2022 and 2024.

Boys Buy Boy Books

The industry's own bestseller list destroys the "boys don't read" excuse.

Dav Pilkey's Dog Man has more than 70 million copies in print in 48 languages. Dog Man: Big Jim Begins sold nearly 1.1 million copies in the U.S. alone.

Jeff Kinney's Diary of a Wimpy Kid has passed 300 million copies worldwide.

In Umesi's junior-reviewer applications, 27 of 30 boys named a boy-led favorite. 67% of boys named no girl-led favorite. Only 46% of girls named no boy-led favorite.

Run those numbers and the business case writes itself. A boy-led book reaches nearly every boy and more than half the girls. A girl-led book loses most of the boys. Umesi drew from self-selected applicants, not a scientific sample, but booksellers report the same thing. Melissa LaSalle, children's buyer at Old Town Books in Alexandria, Virginia, told The Atlantic that parents of boys keep asking for boy heroes. She keeps reaching for backlist: Artemis Fowl, Al Capone Does My Shirts.

Meanwhile the big houses keep shrinking their kids' lists. Penguin Young Readers shut down Dial Books for Young Readers in March, ending an imprint that dated to 1961 and put out roughly 65 titles a year. Macmillan dissolved Roaring Brook Press weeks later. Customers keep asking for a product, and the industry keeps cutting the shelf.

Why This Matters for Authors

Parents, grandparents, teachers and homeschool families want boy heroes, humor, action, sports, gaming and adventure. The 2026 lists give them thin pickings.

You don't need a Big Five green light to fill that gap. Risk-averse acquisitions left it wide open for indie and small-press authors.

Lead with comp titles that already sell to boys: Wimpy Kid, Dog Man, Gordon Korman humor, Percy Jackson-style adventure.

Graphic novels hook boys. Prose with the same pace, humor and stakes keeps them. Put the boy and the action on the cover.

Pitching traditional? Name the gap and the buyer: "Parents of 8-to-12-year-old boys keep asking for this, and the current lists underserve them."

Going indie? Those same parents become your direct-to-reader market.

Publishing spent a decade telling boys the shelf belonged to someone else. A lot of boys believed it. Authors who write for them now walk into a market with eager buyers and thin competition.

Sources:

Commentary

Thomas: Publishing has stopped writing for boys, and the boys have stopped reading. Finally, somebody actually did the statistical analysis.

Matthew: The Atlantic's post must be why my feed was suddenly full of the whole thing about how boys aren't reading, and how it's a bad thing that they don't want to read stories about girls, because they should conform to our tastes and we should never conform to theirs.

Thomas: One test I always use to see if something is truly egalitarian is whether you can flip it. If you flip that statement and say, "Girls should just read stories with male protagonists," there would be pushback. People would say, "No, we need representation. Girls want to read about girls!" Okay, so that's the standard, if you're actually an egalitarian.

I don't really believe egalitarians exist. I think everyone is pretending to be an egalitarian as a motte-and-bailey, and they're really something other than that. But if you are a true egalitarian, you should care about representation going both ways.

Matthew: So 2.14 girls for every boy. That sounds really good if you're in college, and not if you're on the shelf.

Thomas: What this doesn't measure is the kind of boys featured in these books. They're often very wimpy, effeminate boys, like Diary of a Wimpy Kid, which boy readers don't want to read about.

Historically, they want to read about King Arthur-type characters, Boromir and Aragorn-type characters, Conan-type characters, or Henty protagonists. These were manly young men who killed people. They were violent, they went on great adventures, and they always seemed to be fighting Rome.

Henty didn't have a single protagonist who was a Roman, but he had a Carthaginian, a Jew during the sack of the Temple, and lots of other opponents of Rome.

Matthew: I used to work at a major chain bookstore, and I passed a lot of time while shelving books by listening to the Novel Marketing Podcast. You might have heard of it. So I was listening to some of this in real time while shelving those books and talking to customers about what they actually wanted.

When the kids came in, and I'm talking ages eight to 14, the boys very often wanted boy protagonists and things that traditionally appeal to boys, like dragons, knights, and robots.

And the girls often wanted the same thing. When they asked for help or told me what they liked, I'd say about 75% of them wanted the adventure books. The little girls wanted the adventure books. One of them said she wanted anything with a dragon.

It was amazing that they didn't need any help finding the girl stuff. Not because they just picked something off the shelf, but because they already knew what they were supposed to be reading.

Thomas: A comment in the chat says, “It's funny that books with alpha male love interests are so popular.” Yes. The hottest thing in fiction right now is Conan the Barbarian for women. That's romantasy in a nutshell. Nobody seems willing to write Conan the Barbarian for men.

The few people who are, like Larry Correia, are making millions of dollars. He wrote a sword and sorcery series inspired by Conan the Barbarian called Son of the Black Sword. It's now a completed series, it's incredible, it's very well written, and it sold a ton of copies.

But Larry is very much on the outside of the industry. He's technically traditionally published, but he's a special exception. Most people inside the industry, at the big publishers, won't touch Larry and won't publish authors writing the kinds of books he writes, even though his books sell and sell and sell. Readers want that.

I think you could write a Conan the Barbarian-style story that appeals to both men and women. There's enough overlap between what men are looking for and what women are looking for that if you land that overlap and write a Fourth Wing-style book that also appeals to men, you could be the biggest author, period.

Matthew: I have seen those, but half of them are written by the Japanese.

Thomas: It's telling. Recently, the top two movies at the box office were foreign-made films. Hollywood has lost the plot. They're so far off the zeitgeist that somebody from a different country and an entirely different culture can make something more resonant for American filmgoers than Hollywood can.

There's a lot of opportunity here if you're willing to adapt a little to what readers want.

Matthew: Commenter Age of Aquarius Rising asks whether biographies would appeal to boys. I don't have recent experience on that, 10 years ago, I was working at the bookstore and helping out heavily at homeschool book fairs. My observation was that, yes, boys will read a biography if it's an adventure or about something they're already interested in. If you've got a kid who loves inventions, a book about Thomas Edison will probably go over very well. But the biographies that work are normally very adventurous.

Someone in the chat mentioned The Fat Electrician series. That's absolutely a great option. I'm getting a copy for my boys.

Thomas: Stay tuned for more about those Fat Electrician books. I suspect they will sell well and maybe shake up the industry. It will be very easy for people inside publishing to say, "It's successful because he's a famous YouTuber." That misses the point of why he's famous. The Fat Electrician is famous because he can tell a biography in a very entertaining way.

He tells it in a very adult way, though, which is why he's had to make a whole pivot for his children's books. My sons will have to get a lot older before I let them watch a Fat Electrician video, because he will expand their vocabulary.

That works for his brand and for what he's doing, but it doesn't work for a children-facing brand, which means he had to start all over.

Commenter Hissy Cat points out that Conan goes into the public domain in 2028, so now is the time. You can start writing a Conan the Barbarian story right now, and by January 1, 2028, you can publish it.

But be careful, because not all of Conan goes public domain. The character himself does, but not his whole world. There are a bunch of Conan stories, and they roll into the public domain over time. The most famous women in Conan's life will still be copyrighted for a while, so I would just create a new female lead.

Matthew: The thing to remember about stories going into the public domain is that they always enter on January 1, not on the day they were published.

If you really want to delve into that, make a list of the stories by publication year and group them together. Each group comes of age on January 1 of its year, and then you have a list of everything you're allowed to publish, conveniently matched to your publishing cycle. This also works for anything else you want to grab from the public domain.

Thomas: One commentor mentions publishers wanting to protect children from difficult topics and situations. That's true in some ways and not in others. The publishing industry is very intent on presenting very young children with as much sexual content and gender-based content as possible, so I don't think that's true overall.

But it is true when it comes to violence. They're happy to talk about multiple genders and what people do behind closed doors, but they're not happy to talk about strong men doing strong deeds to bring justice to the bad guys.

I have a story world I tell my children at night sometimes. It features Sir George, who's inspired by St. George and the dragon, so it's that kind of world crossed with George MacDonald's The Princess and the Goblin.

In the most recent story, Sir George is going through the woods with a caravan when bandits attack. Sir George and his crew kill some of the bandits and capture the others. Then Sir George executes the bandits. It gave me an opportunity to talk to my children about justice, order, and law.

This is not the kind of story they will encounter in any of the books they're reading. Sir George lives in a very hard world, and he's trying to bring order to a hard world.

And they love it. They beg me for these stories every night. I think part of the reason is that the only place they can get them is from me. I couldn't think of a single story I could recommend to my children about bringing order to chaos, establishing law, or a king.

All the stories for kids are about bands of misfits on the edges of society. There are no stories about kings or barons. At this point in the story, the king has made Sir George a baron and given him a castle out in the marcher lands. He's a borderland baron protecting the frontier from bandits, but also fighting dragons and the rest of it.

They're very fun stories for children. They're not well told, but there's not a lot of competition. There are no other dads telling these stories to my kids, so it's got to be me.

Matthew: I could do an entire Zeitgeist segment on this topic, because I've been talking about it for years. Kingdom building is an actual sub-sub-sub-subgenre, especially in fantasy, and it can show up in science fiction. It's also known as base building or town building.

It's very popular on Royal Road, and it's gotten a lot more popular in the last month or so. There are a bunch of kingdom-building stories on the Rising Stars list, because people actually want that.

Royal Road's audience trends young sometimes. You've got a lot of teenagers in there. So if you want curated stories to give your kids, some of them are on Royal Road.

Thomas: Seth Ring dabbles in some of this kingdom building, but I can tell he gets bored with it. His character will be at home building a kingdom, then go off on an adventure for two books and leave his kingdom in the hands of caretakers. And you're like, "No, stay. Be the king."

Matthew: In my case, I have a story on Royal Road. It's science fiction, and I suppose it's sort of empire building, but that's going to take a few books.

It's called The Best Defense, and it's posted under Novel Ninja, my usual online name and the name of my editing business.

I named my business Novel Ninja because I believe editors should be neither seen nor heard. The reader shouldn't notice our presence at all. That's another reason I don't work off testimonials from authors. My work needs to stand on its own, and theirs should stand without me.

The story is called The Best Defense because Earth is threatened by two totalitarian alien empires that have been at war with each other since the age of the pyramids. There's absolutely no hope for Earth, except that the people of Earth have a saying, "The best defense is a good offense." If you go to novelninja.net, there's a link directly to the story on Royal Road.

Thomas: For professional editors, the referral business is really where it's at. For somebody like Matthew, who doesn't do a lot of advertising, a referral from one successful author to another is where you really pick up clients.

Matthew: Almost everything I get is either a referral or comes from talking about something in a forum like Author Media Social. If you're not in Author Media Social, I highly recommend it. It's a good place.

Podcast Host Directory 2.0 is Here

I rebuilt our Podcast Host Directory 2.0. The directory is older than the Patron Toolbox. It had been neglected. A simple tweak turned into a full interface rebuild. Better search does not cut into usage. Episode search surfaces a show when its episodes cover your topic, even if the show’s overall topic is different. A parenting show that talks about homeschooling appears in a homeschooling search. Results rank by relevance. Off-topic shows and audiobook spam go to the bottom.

Show Contact Info includes the host’s name, how often it publishes, a description, and latest episodes with links and any listed guests. Open your pitch with a genuine compliment on a real episode. Show names link to the podcast’s own website, never to Apple Podcasts. The Frequent Guests badge marks shows that often bring guests on. Filters cover the last 3, 6, or 12 months, category, and language that defaults to the browser. Show more grows the list 50 shows at a time. A short result set looks a little wider and tells you it did.

Included with a Novel Marketing patron membership of $10 a month or more, along with the rest of the Patron Toolbox. Run a search for your book’s topic. If a search misses a show you know should be there, tell us the search and the show.

Commentary

Thomas: The Podcast Host Directory is not an AI tool. It doesn't use any AI, and it doesn't draw on your tokens or credits as a Patron Toolbox member.

Someone requested a feature to show only podcasts that have had an episode in recent months, because many great podcasts haven't put out a new episode in a year, and you don't want to pitch those. It doesn't matter how good your pitch is. They're not going to take it because they’re no longer publishing.

But once I started updating and fixing it, the whole thing got overhauled. It's better and faster. The search doesn't just cover shows and their descriptions. It also searches episodes.

Let's say you talk about homeschooling. A parenting podcast with an episode about homeschooling might appear, which is good. You don't have to be on a homeschooling podcast to talk about homeschooling. A parenting podcast that occasionally does episodes on homeschooling is also really good.

As always, thank you so much for your feedback. Your whining, complaining, and suggesting new features is where all the improvements in the Patron Toolbox come from. And you don't have to apologize. You don't have to be mean about it, but some people say, "Oh, I'm so sorry, but here's an idea for an improvement." Don't apologize. This is a great idea. Or this idea is okay, but maybe not for right now.

Readers Leave Because the Newsletter Is Boring

Most authors blame their email schedule when readers hit unsubscribe. But readers leave because the email is boring.

In our latest Novel Marketing episode, we sit down with Elle E. Kay, a Carol Award finalist with more than two dozen novels who sends her own newsletter every week. One sample from the talk: stop agonizing over clever subject lines. Her most effective one is usually just “Elle’s Newsletter” plus the date. AI-generated versions did worse. What drives the open is the from line, because readers decide based on every past email you sent them.

This episode is for authors who email a list and watch it shrink. We also cover the one schedule rule that lands you in spam, why a fancy AI template can hurt, what to write when your next book is a year away, and the kind of book recommendation that drove unsubscribes.

Listen free or read the blog version on Author Media.

Technology

ChatGPT Wallet Lets Agents Buy Direct From Authors and Amazon Still Blocks the Bots

According to OpenAI's November 13 announcement, ChatGPT Wallet is the first wallet that lets agents pay without seeing a user's real card details and that requires a security check on every purchase. The agent uses a network payment token. The user reviews the items, the total, and the card, then approves with Face ID or a fingerprint. Card rewards and dispute protections stay in place. Users transact directly with the business, which keeps the customer relationship and control over pricing, fulfillment, returns, and customer service.

What Happened

OpenAI built the wallet with American Express, Mastercard, and Visa. It begins rolling out today inside dots, the always-on agents OpenAI introduced on September 29, 2026. Each dot has its own cloud computer and browser. Wallet lives only in a conversation with a user's dot, not in ordinary Chat, Work, or Codex threads. Access starts with ChatGPT Pro subscribers who are 18 or older, in the US, using eligible US-issued cards. OpenAI says 1.2 billion people use ChatGPT each week, many for product research. Later, users may set spending limits and categories for pre-approved buys. CNBC reports that OpenAI is not taking a cut of transactions at launch.

This is not the Instant Checkout OpenAI launched on September 29, 2025 with Etsy sellers and planned for Shopify, powered by the Agentic Commerce Protocol. That in-chat flow was scaled back in March 2026 toward product discovery and merchant-run checkout. Wallet is the agent finishing the purchase on the merchant's own site after the user approves. The protocol still matters for product feeds.

Amazon continues to block outside AI agents. It blocked Meta's Muse on September 20, 2026. Its robots.txt disallows OpenAI bots among others, and its Conditions of Use let it limit agents at its discretion. TechCrunch notes that Amazon steers users to its own Alexa for Shopping. OpenAI itself warns that some sites may unintentionally block agent purchases through CDNs, firewalls, or fraud systems that flag legitimate agent buys.

OpenAI published a Commerce Partner Playbook the same day. Businesses can claim their business in ChatGPT and upload a product feed with current pricing and availability, configure CDNs or firewalls to recognize Web Bot Auth signed requests, work with payment and risk providers (Stripe, Adyen, Checkout.com; fraud partners Forter, Riskified, Sardine, Signifyd), and optionally build a plugin or add WebMCP tools. Browser access does not require a plugin or feed.

Shopify has already opened checkout to browser-based agents via WebMCP, including Shop Pay, for eligible merchants. Stripe is a named partner for Wallet. Support for BookFunnel, Payhip, Gumroad, and WooCommerce stores is unconfirmed as of today. Authors on those platforms should check whether their storefront blocks agents and whether their payment provider recognizes the tokens.

Why Authors Care

A reader can ask ChatGPT for the next book in a series and have the agent buy it from the author's own store. The author keeps the margin and the customer email instead of handing both to Amazon.

Amazon's habit of blocking outside agents, plus Kindle lock-in and KU, means many readers stay put. Near-term impact is small because the feature is Pro-only and US-only.

Authors who sell direct should make sure their store is not blocking AI agents, get series order, formats, and prices into a form ChatGPT can read, claim the business if available, and check whether the platform and payment processor support agent checkout.

Who wins: authors with agent-friendly direct stores and the card networks. Who loses: authors whose sites accidentally block bots, and Amazon if agents successfully divert purchases over time. What to watch: expansion beyond Pro and the US, merchant adoption rates, and whether major platforms document agent support.

Sources:

Commentary

Thomas: This is part of a big trend where more people are using agents to shop for them. It's going to have a big impact on how readers buy books and how many of them use Amazon, because Amazon is blocking all of these agents. If you sell direct, this could be some of the best news you've heard all day.

Matthew: People have been saying ChatGPT is doing this to catch up to Grok, but this is actually something they've been talking about for a very long time.

Thomas: They've promised this feature and done press releases on it over and over again, on and off, around Shopify. I always test it by asking ChatGPT to buy Jonathan Shuerger’s book. And it says, "Here's a link for you to buy it on your own." So the feature doesn't exist yet. ChatGPT is promising it yet again, but this is a slightly better version of the feature.

Matthew: A security check on every purchase means no accidental purchases. That is always good. That's the main thing people have been afraid of.

Thomas: If it's only in Dots currently, this is a limited rollout, because I think you need at least the $100.00-a-month plan to unlock Dots. Dots is ChatGPT's knockoff version of Grok Bot, but it will eventually roll out to more plans.

To understand how this works technically, let's say your house flooded and you've got contractors coming and going.

You can give a contractor a key to your house, and then they can come and go anytime. But they could also go to Home Depot and duplicate your key without you knowing, give you back your key, and now they have a key to your house. That's the concern with giving ChatGPT your credit card number. They could store it and use it somewhere else without your permission.

The new system is like leaving your key with a neighbor you trust and telling them, "When Plumber Joe comes, he has permission to come in my house." Plumber Joe knocks on the neighbor's door, and the neighbor opens your door. So Plumber Joe has access to your house, but he never has the key in his possession.

It's the exact same system. You give access without giving the actual number. The credit card number is held in an encrypted vault ChatGPT can't see, but it has permission to use it in a very specific way. This is very similar to how Grok Bot handles credit card information, and I believe how Muse handles it.

Muse is the real story here, because it already has something like 20 million users, an astronomically high number. The number one use case on Muse is shopping. That means a Muse agent could come to your store, if you're using Curios or Payhip or something on your author website, buy your book, and give it to the human, and at no point was Amazon ever touched.

At some point Amazon will yield, but until it does, this is the golden age of selling direct. You sell direct to the human, but the agent is the one typing in the credit card information. The main hurdle is people saying, "I don't want to go to an author's website and type in my shipping address, my billing address, and my credit card. I want one-click checkout."

Well, Muse through your author website, or OpenAI's new wallet system, is zero-click checkout. "Hey, ChatGPT, go buy me this book from Matthew Bowman." It goes off and comes back with, "Please confirm. The book is $15.99. Are you sure you want to pay with your Visa?" You say, "Yes, confirm, pay with my Visa," and it buys it and delivers it.

For Amazon, which competes with a one-click checkout, that's terrifying. Something's got to give with Amazon. Right now they've got the walls up. They can block Muse, no problem. They can block Grok Bot, sort of, but there are ways Grok Bot can get around it.

They can't block OpenClaw or Hermes or any of the high-level wizard harnesses. Amazon does not have a good way to block those agentic tools or even see that you're using them. I was talking with somebody who uses OpenClaw, and he said, "I have it shop for me on Amazon all the time with no problems, because to Amazon it looks like me doing it." Amazon doesn't know it's secretly the bot moving the cursor and clicking the buttons the whole time.

Matthew: If you look at OpenAI's playbook and you're saying, "I still don't understand this," well, you're already working with AI. Feed it into your AI and say, "Please explain this to me like I'm an author."

Thomas: Or just say, "Grok Bot, set this up for me." It can log into your website and get it configured.

Mary asks, "An agent would be able to purchase an ebook and then automatically email it to your Kindle, correct?" Yes, if you have your website set up correctly. The two methods I recommend are Curios, which I just did an episode about, a brand-new platform that handles everything in one place and can deliver the ebook to your Kindle, or a Payhip plus BookFunnel integration, which can also deliver it straight to your Kindle.

Other setups work, but those are the two where you don't have to bother with sales tax returns, which are a huge hassle and not worth it for the numbers most authors do on their websites.

Matthew: If a reader wants to keep track of when a favorite author releases a new book, they can set up a routine with their AI bot to check for new books by favorite authors. With this wallet, it can almost buy the book the same day, because you still have to confirm.

You don't have to think, "I'll buy that later at work." One touch, and it's bought and ready for you to read after work. Or during work, but we won't tell your boss.

Thomas: The decadent Roman Empire of Amazon has the barbarians at the gates, and it doesn't realize how scary that can be. At no point does Amazon get touched. What you just described, an agent checking the author's website automatically, is something readers normally rely on Amazon for: "I got an email from Amazon that my favorite author has a new book out."

Matthew: And that's really unreliable. Sometimes I get updates from authors I follow but often I don’t.

Thomas: It’s very unreliable. I've gotten emails from Audible that book four was out from an author I enjoy, and I'm like, "Wait, book three came out? Audible, I bought and listened to books one and two. At no point did you tell me about book three, and now you're telling me about book four." For a long time you couldn't even easily tell which was book one, two, or three. It was a huge, high-friction experience.

Now they have slightly better series reporting, so I can at least see that I haven't read book three yet and go back to it. But I wanted to know about book three when it came out.

This is a really broken system, and it's a system we're going to fix completely outside of Amazon.

Microsoft Herded Your Manuscript Into the Cloud Then the Cloud Went Dark

According to Microsoft's Own Status Dashboard

Microsoft 365 collapsed worldwide on Thursday, November 12, and the company still hasn't fully recovered. Outlook, Exchange Online, Teams, SharePoint and Copilot all went down around midday U.S. time, according to Microsoft's service health updates under incidents EX1550543 and MO1550821.

Downdetector logged nearly 130,000 Outlook complaints at the peak. The outage reached 74 countries and territories, according to the Washington Post. Microsoft says it found no sign of hackers.

Nobody attacked Microsoft. Microsoft broke Microsoft.

How Microsoft Took Down Its Own Cloud

Microsoft's status updates read like a disaster movie in slow motion. Servers across the network started failing automated health checks Thursday afternoon, and Microsoft's systems pulled them out of service. The surviving servers inherited the extra work and buckled.

Microsoft insisted user traffic never spiked. Its own machinery created the overload.

A process that sets up secure connections on each server "becomes overwhelmed, causing the servers to stop processing requests," Microsoft wrote overnight.

Engineers restarted the servers. The servers choked again once traffic returned. Microsoft then started rolling back "a recent network configuration change that correlates with the start of impact."

On Friday, Microsoft blamed "an issue during an earlier network capacity upgrade" and apologized. Translation: Microsoft pushed a change, and the change knocked out the world's office software. Microsoft promised a full Post-Incident Report but hasn't published one.

By Friday afternoon, Microsoft said email service had started approaching normal levels, though intermittent problems may continue.

Who Got Hit

The damage spread far beyond office workers missing a few emails. Courts, schools, airlines, brokerages, government offices and healthcare companies all reported disruptions, according to the Washington Times.

Australian federal police, Australian intelligence agencies, and government systems in Japan and Singapore lost access. Baltimore County staff couldn't send or receive email. Eli Lilly, which runs Microsoft 365 for roughly 40,000 employees, landed on the affected list. A Manchester criminal trial ground to a halt, and Britain's National Pharmacy Association warned of prescription delays.

Microsoft Pushed You Into This Cloud

Ordinary users didn't wander into this mess. Microsoft herded them there.

In August 2025, Microsoft announced that Word for Windows would save new documents straight to OneDrive by default, with AutoSave switched on from the first keystroke.

In January 2025, Microsoft jammed Copilot into Microsoft 365 Personal and Family and raised the price $3 a month. Microsoft hadn't raised U.S. prices on those plans since launching them in 2013.

This week, Copilot crashed with everything else. Microsoft warned that Copilot Chat might not load, answer, or reach your email, calendar or files. You paid extra for the AI. The AI couldn't find your files either.

Why Authors Should Care

Some users reported they couldn't reach their OneDrive storage at all. A manuscript that lives only in the cloud lives at Microsoft's mercy.

Editor, agent and reader email sat in limbo. Microsoft stretched its email timeout window to 48 hours so delayed messages wouldn't bounce. Microsoft calls that mail delayed, not lost.

Microsoft warned that Teams calendars and meeting scheduling could fail, which puts calls with editors and agents at risk.

Microsoft's 2026 rap sheet already included a nearly 10-hour outage in January and an authentication meltdown that dragged into a second day at the end of August.

What to Do Before the Next One

  • Keep your working draft on your own hard drive, plus a second backup that Microsoft doesn't control.
  • Uncheck "Create new files in the cloud automatically" on the Save page of Word's Options if you want new files to stay local.
  • Save your editor's and agent's phone numbers today.
  • Never stake a launch-day email blast on a single provider.
  • Check your inbox for stragglers once Microsoft clears the backlog.

Microsoft wants your words on its servers, your money for its AI, and your faith in its uptime. This week it fumbled all three. Own your manuscript. Rent the cloud as a backup, never as your only copy.

Sources:

Commentary

Thomas: You handed Microsoft your manuscript, they stored it securely in the cloud, and then the cloud went dark.

If you use Outlook, you're not getting any email. When X or Facebook goes down, it goes down for everybody, so your inbox doesn't fill up on those platforms, because no one can send or receive. But everyone outside of Microsoft land has been sending and receiving email with no problem, which means your inbox is going to be packed when email finally gets turned back on.

If you've been storing your files in the cloud and only in the cloud, you can't edit your manuscript right now. That's a real problem, and one of the big weaknesses of a cloud-only approach to storing your documents. If you lose access to the cloud, you lose access to your documents.

The rule of thumb for backups is 3-2-1. You want three copies of your important documents, stored in two locations, and one of those locations should be off-site.

I have a copy on my computer, I have a network-attached storage device that I back up to, and I also have a cloud backup. It's important to have a copy off-site in case my house were to burn down or flood

So storing backups in the cloud is really good. But when the cloud is the only copy, you end up with a very fragile setup.

This incident has revealed to me that I'm a little overly dependent on Google Docs, which is a cloud-only copy. The only copy of our show notes for this episode exists on Google Docs. If Google Docs went down, this show would be just two guys talking.

Matthew: I have an author who works entirely in Google Docs. Even before this happened, I told him that's maybe not a good idea. He should at least export a copy every so often.

Thomas: You can create systems that keep a copy of all your Google Docs on your computer, but you have to go through the effort to make sure that system exists and stays in sync.

Matthew: Or you can get Grok Bot to set it up for you and back it up automatically.

Thomas: They key is to make it automatic. If it’s not automatic, you'll always lose some amount of information. It could be days. It could be weeks.

Years ago, our office had a conference room next door, and we all left for a staff meeting without locking our door, because we were in a big office building and didn't think we needed to. A Yellow Pages salesman came in to drop off the Yellow Book, saw nobody in the office, walked into my office, unplugged my laptop, and walked out with it.

I came back from the staff meeting, and my laptop was gone. I was like, "That's unfortunate." So I went to the Apple Store, bought a new laptop, plugged it in right where the old one was, pushed the button to restore from backup, and later that day I was back where I left off.

Nothing was missing other than the money in my bank account for the new computer. Because I had automatic backups running through Time Machine, I lost no information and was able to restore it very quickly. That's what your life could be with automatic backups.

Hopefully it never happens. But the only thing more expensive than losing your computer is also losing days of work. So you should have automatic backups.

Why did Microsoft go down?

The real question everyone should be asking is why Microsoft went down. If you look at the technical elements, some Microsoft servers were failing their health checks and rolling over to other Microsoft servers. But because Microsoft is so compute constrained, those servers were getting overloaded and rolling over too. It was a cascade, and that's why they haven't been able to restore the system yet.

We're a day in, and the system wasn't fully restored when we drafted this segment. So check and see if your Outlook is back.

This is what the future is going to look like, because the industry has become compute constrained. Everyone decided data centers are evil and we shouldn't build data centers. What you don't realize is that your Microsoft Outlook runs in a data center. If they're constrained in their compute, suddenly the whole system becomes more fragile.

If they had plenty of data center space, whole data centers they were barely using, a few servers going down would be no problem. They'd have a whole data center full of servers with spare capacity, like a bunch of redwood trees whose roots are all interconnected.

Matthew: By the time people started freaking out about data centers, the ones they were complaining about had already been approved before anyone knew AI was going to be so popular. Those were just for file storage. They use the exact same servers.

The new ones being proposed now are built with AI in mind, but previously it was just data storage. People started freaking out, construction started getting halted, and the people actually building them were asking, "Are we going to have jobs next year?" It's very fragile. Things start getting uncertain, and no one likes an uncertain market.

Thomas: People on Bluesky complaining about data centers don’t realize that Bluesky lives in a data center. Same with people on Threads complaining about data centers. The cloud is just a term for somebody's data center somewhere.

I thought, "We could easily fix this whole moral panic over data centers by renaming them cloud factories." It's just a factory for the cloud. People have received a lot of propaganda to hate data centers, or to feel that a data center in their town somehow harms them more than any other kind of business. I saw a survey saying people would rather have a nuclear power plant nearby than a data center. That's a crazy level of propaganda.

Matthew: I would like that, because then my electricity prices would go down. How about both? Let's do both.

Thomas: A lot of data centers generate electricity, so they can actually make your power prices go down as well.

What's happening is that how much you pay for electricity doesn't correlate with whether a data center is near you. It correlates with how many Democrats you have in charge. If everyone up to your local HOA is a Democrat, you're going to pay California-level rates. If they're all Republicans, you're going to pay Tennessee-level rates.

That's what determines how expensive power is, because Democrats see high power prices as a moral good that helps fight climate change. They actively want to make gas more expensive. That's why I was stunned that they ran on affordability, and why the Republican Party was caught completely flat-footed. Republicans are like, "What are you talking about? You want fuel prices to be high. Your policies purposely make fuel prices high to fight climate change."

Matthew: What Thomas just said is exactly what the people in New York were saying. That's the purpose of the higher prices they instituted there. So don't get angry at Thomas. Those are the Democrats' own words in New York.

The Mob Killed Vellum's MC. A One-Man Mac App Has Already Replaced It

Last week we told you how Vellum launched Automation in version 4.2 on November 4. Automation let authors plug an assistant like Claude into Vellum to grind through the busywork:

Vinci Books manages thousands of titles. Its team called Automation "revolutionary for our production department."

Then the pile-on hit. Emails. Threads posts. And, in Vellum's own words, "a plethora of 🤮 emojis." On November 5, the 3-person team pulled Automation in version 4.2.1.

So is Thomas going to build a Vellum replacement? Looks like someone beat him to the punch.

Enter WriterMorph

A solo developer had already shipped the same idea while the outrage machine took aim at Vellum.

WriterMorph hit the Mac App Store on October 13, and it features MCP Connections. It lets Claude Code, Codex, LM Studio or any other MCP-compatible app on your Mac work inside your open project. It is like a Vellum, Atticus, Plottr Combo for $50.

Nobody stormed WriterMorph with vomit emojis. Nobody noticed it at all. The App Store listing still lacks enough ratings to display a score.

What WriterMorph Won't Do

Don't toss your Vellum license yet. WriterMorph competes with Scrivener, not Vellum. It plans and drafts books with a binder, corkboard, plot canvas and timeline. Vellum formats them. WriterMorph's Compile Studio exports PDF, Word, EPUB, Fountain and Final Draft, with paperback and e-book presets. It makes no claim about passing KDP print preflight. Deckle does. WriterMorph describes its assistant working with the project you have open. Vellum pitched batch jobs across an entire folder of books.

WriterMorph runs only on macOS 15 Sequoia or newer. The iPad version says "coming soon." Windows and Linux users get nothing.

One developer, one month on the market, zero reviews.

Whatever your assistant reads goes to that assistant's company. WriterMorph says so in its own App Store listing.

The Price Tag

The 30-day free trial that counts only the days you open the app. It’s $29.99 through November 30, then $49.99. One purchase covers Mac and the future iPad app. No subscription, no account.

Compare:

  • Scrivener costs $59.99
  • Atticus $147
  • Deckle $197

Why Authors Care

A pile-on can kill a feature at a big-name company. It can't kill every small developer who ships one. Off-by-default protects everyone. Authors who hate AI never see it. Authors who want it flip a switch.

WriterMorph imports Scrivener projects in one step and saves each book as a local file you control. Mac-based Scrivener users can test it free before the sale price ends.

Keep your master files portable. Vellum just proved a company can hand you a feature on Tuesday and take it back on Wednesday.

Vellum folded. WriterMorph shipped. We'll keep tracking which tools let you work the way you choose.

Sources:

Commentary

Thomas: Last week we talked about Vellum turning off its MCP, and it made everybody very angry. I said, "I'll give them one week to put the MCP back, or I might create my own."

Well, this last week I've been flooded with emails from people who have already created Vellum killers. So I'm no longer planning to build my own Vellum competitor.

One, I like Vellum. Two, I think they're going to put the MCP back. Three, there are so many apps that are either out already or coming soon, and we'll be reporting on all of them.

The one I want to feature today, which reached out to me yesterday, is WriterMorph. I've been checking it out, and it's like a combination of Vellum, Scrivener, and Plottr all in one app that's $50.00. If it delivers on its promises, wow. It has an MCP, so you can use Grok Bot or Claude or Codex to format your files. It basically has all of the features I would have put into an app. They already built it.

I think it's $30.00 for the month of November, and it's a one-time purchase. So according to all the features on their website, it's not only the most powerful tool but also the cheapest.

It only runs on Mac, and I think the only way to buy it is through the Mac App Store. So it doesn't do the one thing I was going to do, which was build it in Rust and have it run on Windows and Linux.

I'll probably be announcing other Vellum competitors over the coming weeks as more of these tools come out of the woodwork.

This is not a recommendation. I have not tested WriterMorph. You can get a free demo through the Mac App Store, and then I think you purchase a lifetime license.

Matthew: This is the first I've heard of it. I've settled in pretty firmly on Deckle right now. It doesn't have an MCP. I'm wondering if they'll put one in as a result of this. I send them feedback fairly frequently, because I was one of the early beta testers. I'm hoping they develop the mobile app first, but the MCP would be useful to more people.

Thomas: The benefit of an MCP is not getting AI to write the book for you. It's not even really getting easy editorial feedback on your book. The real advantage is this: I've got 30 books, and I want to put a page announcing my 31st book in the back matter of all 30 books. I want to do it in an intelligent way, giving the AI guidelines on where in the back matter it should go, because there are other elements in the back matter, and I want it to handle it all automatically.

For that kind of task, Grok Bot can do all 30 books in 20 or 30 minutes. It can put in the promo, replace one that needs replacing, or add it, using its judgment based on your feedback. If it has an MCP into a tool that does the typesetting, it can do it very quickly and efficiently, and it can look really good.

Doing that by hand on all 30 books does not make you a better writer. There are things you can do by hand that make you a better writer. For instance, turning off spellcheck and fixing all the spelling on all of your pages by hand with a dictionary and a thesaurus.

That actually makes you a better writer. But swapping out back matter does not. It's something you can automate at no cost to your soul or your skills. So it doesn't make any sense not to have this feature.

WriterMorph also has a typewriter mode. It's literally just a piece of paper. You press the keys on your keyboard, it makes a typewriter sound, there's a click-click-click animation, and then you have to switch to a new page. Totally not useful from a productivity perspective, but that's a cool thing. It's fun. It also has a distraction-free mode.

I suspect the guy who developed this found all the different tools and said, "I want every feature from every tool, all in one super app." That's one approach. I have a lot of calls scheduled with a lot of developers, and this is not the approach I recommend for everyone. There will be one or two apps that pull off the "my app does everything" approach.

But I suspect the easier money actually goes the other way. Create an app that's very opinionated, designed only around the Snowflake Method. If you're writing your book with the Snowflake Method, it's absolutely the very best app for you, because the Snowflake Method is built into every decision of the app. If you're not using the Snowflake Method, it's just not for you.

So if you're the kind of author who has a book on writing, a method, an approach, "Here's how I teach outlining," don't just teach outlining. Create software that follows your philosophy and has it baked into every software decision. For people writing with your approach, that's the best way to do it.

The other opportunity I see in the market is a harness like Codex or Claude Code or Cursor, but for writing books. Something model-agnostic, for a full AI-first writing approach. For somebody who wants to use AI to write, it would be like Cursor. You can swap out different models, it can make tool calls, it has really powerful functionality built in, and it helps guide the LLMs not to write sloppy prose. All of that is fixable with a good harness.

I don't think anybody has built a public harness for writing books. I know many authors who built their own private harnesses, and people who teach, "Here's how to build your own harness," a kind of pseudo-harness. But no one who's pitched me is building an AI-first agentic writing tool, where instead of typing in the words, you give feedback to the AI and it revises.

You can use the existing harnesses. You can use Cursor or Claude Code and Git to write a book. But I suspect most authors need something a little more writerly. They don't want to learn what Git is, even if Git is running behind the scenes.

They just want to create in the masculine way of creation. There are two approaches to creation: the feminine approach and the masculine approach. In the feminine approach, you have to do it all yourself. If somebody else builds it, it's not yours.

In the masculine approach, you plant the seed of the idea, somebody else does the initial work, and then you give feedback and correction for the next 18 years. I'm keeping this family-friendly. It's the kingly way of creation. It's the way Solomon built the temple. He had the seed of the idea, planted it into a whole team of people who did the work to build it, and then gave correction and guidance.

That's why, for people operating in the masculine way, working with a ghostwriter just seems efficient. I can work with a dozen ghostwriters and write a dozen books. James Patterson does that.

For somebody in the feminine mode of creation, that's not just wrong. It's evil. It's not just ineffective. It's morally objectionable, because it's not yours. If some other woman has the baby, it's not your baby. No one will believe it's your baby if you didn't give birth to it. But in the masculine form, it's a little different.

This is a theory of AI I'm still developing. It's a way of thinking through the AI debate: there's a gendered approach. That's not to say men can't create in a feminine way, or women can't create in a masculine way, when writing a book. Although it does work that way when creating a person. They have to work together to create a person.

Matthew: If you want to refine that, you can call it the motherhood method and the fatherhood method.

Thomas: There you go.

Matthew: As you were starting that, I was thinking of my father. He never wanted to take credit if someone else had built something for him. But if he went out in the backyard and put together a bookcase himself, and someone came over, he'd say, "Oh yeah, I built that." Of course, he didn't go out and fell the trees by hand.

Thomas: It's the scoutmaster with his cup of coffee, pointing at the scouts as they build a tower with rope and logs, giving the feedback and corrections. "No, that's not how you tie the knot." Then he puts his mug down, goes over, and says, "Let me show you how to do it." He does one lashing correctly and says, "This is how you do it. Now do this a dozen more times."

That's a fatherly approach to creation, and it's very different from, "I will tie every lashing on this tower myself, and I won't allow anyone to help me."

Matthew: I actually have PowerPoint presentations full of methods I used to teach authors, and I haven't taught those classes in a long time. Now I think I need to partner with someone who knows how to develop these apps and load it all in.

Thomas: When I said, "Send me your GitHub links and your resumes," some really impressive developers reached out. Maybe I can get you in touch with them.

Matthew: Phil Greeley just mentioned that WriterMorph is $30.00 until November 30. If you want to try it, that's the time to give it a test drive.

Thomas: Here are the pros and cons of trying new software like this right now. It's brand new, which means for $30.00 you get lifetime access. You'll be grandfathered in, and if this becomes the new hotness, you'll be laughing at all the authors whining about a $20.00-a-month subscription two years from now. That's the good scenario.

On the flip side, this may not become the new hotness. The developer may not make enough money to stay interested, or some other tool ends up winning, and you've lost $30.00 you'll never get back.

So this is not an endorsement. It's a risk. But as risks go, $30.00 is a lot cheaper than Vellum and Scrivener and Plottr and Atticus. All the competing tools are so much more expensive, and I think as these new entrants flood the market, they'll come in at lower price points. I think that's good for authors.

Adobe’s Foray Into Agentic AI

Vellum’s experiment with AI automation lasted roughly a day. Adobe is making it a central part of its creative software—although authors hoping for an official AI connection to InDesign will have to keep waiting.

Vellum introduced optional local automation in version 4.2 on November 4, allowing outside AI assistants to handle repetitive publishing chores, such as regenerating EPUBs or updating back matter across a series. Then came the emails, Threads posts, and what the company described as “a plethora of 🤮 emojis.” Vellum removed the feature in version 4.2.1, saying it had underestimated objections to connecting the software to an outside assistant.

Meanwhile, Adobe’s November 10 announcement laid out a broad expansion of AI agents across Creative Cloud and Firefly. The pitch is straightforward: describe the changes you want, let an assistant perform the steps, and retain an editable project file. Photoshop layers, Illustrator vectors, and Premiere sequences remain available for further work.

For authors, that could mean faster cover variations, promotional graphics, book trailers, and interior formatting. But the announcement bundles together several different technologies and release schedules, and the distinctions matter.

Adobe previewed local connections using Model Context Protocol, or MCP, that would let outside assistants such as ChatGPT, Claude, or Gemini work directly in Photoshop, Illustrator, Premiere, and After Effects. A private beta is scheduled for early 2027.

Notice which book-production application is missing: InDesign.

Adobe has not announced that InDesign will join that beta or provided a timetable for adding it. Authors looking for an official replacement for Vellum’s abandoned connection therefore do not have one on Adobe’s announced schedule.

InDesign does, however, have its own AI Assistant in beta. According to Adobe’s documentation, it can handle tasks such as setting margins and grids, updating typography, resizing objects, managing swatches, checking for overset text or missing alt text, and rewriting copy. Changes can be inspected and reversed through document history.

That offers potential relief from tedious layout work. But Adobe has not described a catalog-wide system that opens dozens of separate books, updates their back matter, and exports fresh editions—the kind of workflow that made Vellum’s short-lived automation appealing.

Independent developers are already offering another route. Community-built InDesign MCP servers and products such as Sidekick for InDesign connect AI assistants to the application through scripting and local bridges. Those options may interest technically comfortable authors and small presses, although they remain separate from Adobe’s official MCP initiative.

Beyond book interiors, Adobe is expanding its own assistants across its creative apps and positioning Firefly as an AI creative studio. Its beta assistant includes a planning mode for reviewing proposed steps and a model selector for choosing which system performs a task. Other tools support reusable workflows and image, video, and design production. Much of that remains in beta or preview, so authors should distinguish demonstrations from features they can use today.

Adobe’s direction has drawn criticism from artists and technology commentators, but the company is continuing its rollout. Vellum encountered enough resistance to withdraw its feature almost immediately.

For independent authors, the practical question is how much useful production work these assistants can reliably handle. Consistent typography, updated back matter, and promotional variations can consume hours that might otherwise go toward writing. Automation could reduce that burden, while cover judgment, brand consistency, and final production checks still require attention.

For now, Vellum has closed its official connection, Adobe is building several, and InDesign occupies an awkward middle ground: an internal assistant in beta, third-party automation available, and no announced place in Adobe’s official local MCP rollout.

Commentary

Thomas: There's a lot of positive news for authors today. In other positive news, we actually have a positive Adobe story. They're adding MCP connectors and AI integration to a lot of their tools, so you get the power of Adobe while just whining to Claude or Grok Bot instead of having to do it yourself.

Matthew: Vellum tried it for a day and then ran away, but Adobe is making it a central part of its creative software.

Thomas: InDesign is the one you use for making books, and it's the one that didn't get an MCP connector. But InDesign does have an AI built into it, so you can just talk to InDesign to rework your book.

I don’t recommend InDesign because it is so complicated. I still don't recommend Adobe products, but they are adding MCP connectors and starting to embrace this new headless approach. Instead of using the software, you chat with Grok Bot or Claude and it uses the software for you, so you don't have to become an expert at InDesign or Photoshop to use InDesign or Photoshop.

It's good that Adobe is improving the code and the power of its tools. My biggest problem with Adobe is that it has a very abusive subscription that's very difficult to get out of. In fact, it's famously one of the hardest subscriptions to cancel.

I think they charge you a fee for canceling. You think you have a monthly subscription, but technically it's an annual subscription, and if you cancel early, they hit you with a fee.

So I still wouldn't use an Adobe product. But if you're already using one, you can now drive it with Grok Bot or Claude, and that's incredible.

Claude Fable 5.2 Tops Fiction Bench Story Scores but Readers Rank It Lower

According to Fiction Bench, Anthropic’s Claude Fable 5.2 ranks first among 39 models for Story (84.1), Intelligence (89.3), and Prose quality (90.5) on the run completed November 9–11. Its Human rating is 975 (±107, 37 votes), which is lower than most models on the board. Because the Overall score weights human preference at 60 percent, story and prose at 10 percent each, and intelligence at 20 percent, Fable 5.2 lands at 63.1 and ninth place.

That gap is the practical question for novelists. AI judges give it the highest marks for plot, character, world-building, and prose. Human readers, voting blind on short scenes, prefer other models more often. Claude Opus 5.5 sits second overall at 66.3 with a Human rating of 1,027 (119 votes) and costs half as much. Fable 5.1, the previous version, scored 63.5 overall with a Human rating of 1,003.

What Happened

According to Anthropic’s announcement on November 9, Fable 5.2 and Mythos 5.2 are the same underlying model. Fable carries cybersecurity and biology safeguards and is available to all users. Mythos is restricted to organizations that pass the Cyber or Life Sciences Verification Programs. Outputs run up to 30 percent faster than Fable 5.1 / Mythos 5.1. Pricing is $8 per million input tokens and $40 per million output tokens, down from $10 / $50 on the prior version. An optional fast mode is up to 2.5 times quicker at $16 / $80.

Anthropic still recommends Opus 5.5 as the strongest daily driver for most tasks. Fable is positioned for the most ambitious open-ended technical work and can act as an Advisor or Orchestrator for smaller models. Testers said it communicates more clearly; one Cognition engineer noted that it “says it doesn’t know things instead of hallucinating.” Safety blocks dropped about 55 percent versus Fable 5.1 (60 percent fewer in cyber, 40 percent fewer in biology). Blocked queries fall back to Opus 4.8 or Opus 5.

On the technical side, Anthropic reports that 1,000 Fable 5.2 agents formalized Fermat’s Last Theorem in 30 hours, solved two open black-hole physics problems, designed three working electronic devices, and built a bootable prototype operating system with more than 1,000 subagents over eight days. Those demos are not fiction results.

The Fiction Bench sample page for run b5be9c0026a5bc06 shows the model completed all 20 stories. Chapter averages and Final scores sit in the mid-to-high 80s for most genres. Standouts include Ancient Roman Historical Fiction (Final 90.8), Comedic Horror (90.4), Cozy Fantasy (90.1), Hardboiled Mystery (90.2), and Cosmic Horror (90.0). Legal Thriller finished at 82.6 and Romcom at 84.6. The page marks Spicy Scene as Yes. Writing cost for the full benchmark run was $41.95. Claude Mythos 5.2 does not appear on the leaderboard.

Why Authors Care

Fable 5.2 leads the AI-judge categories that track story craft and prose, yet the human vote that drives 60 percent of the Overall score is lower than Opus 5.5 and Fable 5.1.

At $8 / $40 it is twice the token price of Opus 5.5 ($4 / $20). The benchmark writing cost of $41.95 versus roughly $13–$14 for Opus reflects that gap on a full set of stories.

This week, eligible paid plans receive one to three Fable usage resets, and Fable usage counts for up to 50 percent of weekly limits on Pro and Team standard seats. That is the practical window to test it without burning the entire allowance.

For most daily fiction drafting, Anthropic’s own guidance points to Opus 5.5. Reserve Fable for scenes or problems where the higher judge scores on intelligence and prose might show up in your specific genre, then compare the output blind against Opus.

Mythos 5.2 is unavailable to ordinary authors. It is the unsafeguarded version for vetted cyber and life-sciences labs only.

Sources:

Commentary

Thomas: Fable 5.2 is out, just in time for Anthropic's big IPO next week, and it's the newest, best model for coding in some cases. Go to bench.storyhacker.ai to see benchmarks on all the different AI models and how they do for writing.

They have a bunch of automated benches, which tend to be dominated by the Claude models, and then they have humans blind test the models against each other. The Claude models do not do well there.

In fact, the number one model with humans is GPT 6.1 Tera, which has shocked me personally. I'm starting to switch Patron Toolbox tools over to GPT 6.1 Tera, which I'm also shocked by, because historically I've used hardly any OpenAI models. But Tera does better than Sol, which is more expensive. Tera is faster, it's really good at writing, and in my initial tests it's less sloppy. I do a lot of testing before I change models behind the scenes.

The problem with Claude is that it starts to sound like Claude. People have a term for it: Claudish. It's not as good at writing as it used to be. I think people liked it more early on, when they'd never heard Claudish before. Now that they're getting familiar with it, it's getting fatiguing.

Tera is number one ranked by humans, number two is Gemini 4 Argon, and number three is Gemini 3.7 Flash. I wonder whether these models rank high just because they're less popular.

There's something to be said for not using the model everyone tells you to use. If everybody uses the same model, it all has a sameness to it, especially if they all use the same approach.

Matthew: My website has a list of rules or guidelines. One of those rules is to type everything yourself. Whatever you generate with AI, type it out yourself, and you retain your own voice. Even if you think the AI had a really good turn of phrase, you might come up with something different as you go along.

Thomas: That will also protect you from watermarking. All of the tools either have watermarks now or will have them soon to comply with EU regulations, so there won't be much getting around that. Maybe the Chinese models won't do it. I'm not sure.

But those watermarks get rubbed off the more you interact with the text yourself. With the amount of editing you do, or typing it out while using only some words here and there, no watermark will survive that level of human entropy.

Matthew: For an example of Claudish, think of an author you enjoyed but who had little tics. I think of an author whose characters always did everything “inwardly.” They sighed inwardly. They rolled their eyes inwardly. My favorite was "he swallowed inwardly," because I'm not sure how else you swallow.

Those kinds of tics show up in AI writing, which is why I don't like using it for line editing. Always have a human look over your line editing. The AI doesn't understand beauty. It understands statistically generated efficiency.

Thomas: And patterns. It's really good at creating new patterns from old patterns, but it struggles when it comes to developing taste. Although the new Fable 5.2 is supposed to do well on taste tests, at least in design. People using it for design are finding that it's a slightly more opinionated model.

The Fable line has historically been a more opinionated model, which is both its greatest strength and its greatest weakness, depending on whether you agree with its opinions. If you agree with its opinions, it's like a super genius that does what you would do, but instead of you.

I haven't played with Fable 5.2 a lot myself. I've been mainlining Opus for a lot of my development, and I've found that Opus 5.5, at least for the level of development I'm doing, is basically perfect. It has solved every problem I've handed it, and I'm very happy with it.

I don't typically write with AI, although I use Opus 5.5 to help rewrite things for this show. I haven't yet tested Tera for that.

Zeitgeist Report: What is "Slopcore" and why is it actually good?

Thomas: It's time for the Zeitgeist Report, our new podcast. It's a podcast within a podcast, just about culture and politics and how people and their preferences are changing. Not just how they've changed, but how they're changing, so you can skate to where the puck is headed.

If you have a friend who's interested in the culture side of this, we have a YouTube playlist of just the Zeitgeist Reports, and we have a podcast at zeitgeistreport.com. And we're going to try something we've never done before.

We're going to react to some music videos. Matthew is going to react, and you can react in the chat as well. These are music videos from an emerging genre called slopcore, and it's surprisingly cerebral.

So much of modern music is written to the lowest common denominator. It's very stupid, and it's often about only three or four different topics. Songs aren't even about romance now. Now they're just about the urges, the physical act. We went from an innuendo you had to decode, where a child didn't know what the song was about, to songs like "WAP." I won't say what WAP stands for. That's where pop music has gone.

What's happening with slopcore is that these songs are part of a debate or conversation about philosophy, and slopcore is specifically about AI. As a genre, it's not pro-AI and it's not anti-AI. It's the debate over AI, discussing AI and sometimes just covering AI news. These musicians who use AI to create music are having a debate among themselves about whether it's art.

I find that very interesting, because using AI to create a song and using AI to create a book are that same fatherly, as opposed to motherly, mode of creation. Are you planting the seed and letting it grow, or are you doing it all yourself, inside yourself?

I'm going to play a song, and we may pause it and comment on it. You can comment on it as well. This is "Drop the Prompt," and DegenerativePixels is the name of the YouTube channel.

[Song plays: the narrator describes grinding through dozens of takes, multiple drafts, and repeated revisions on an AI-made track, while people keep asking him to just hand over the short prompt so they can one-shot their own version.]

Thomas: This is capturing a couple of different approaches. One is that they're describing what's often called roulette prompting, where you try different prompts to see which ones work. That itself is a form of creation, because you're using your taste to judge. You type in the prompt for what you want, send it to the machine, get a response, and then use your human judgment to say, "That's not any good."

"One shot" is a term in the AI community for when you put in a prompt, get the response, and send it out. You're not using any judgment. You're just taking what the AI gives you and running with it.

Matthew: I liked the bit of humor where he sings about fixing words that land too late, and the words in that line land late on purpose as a demonstration.

This is very interesting for me, because my wife is a professional musician. She's a church organist, so she has opinions about proper music and where the notes should land. So this is amusing.

Thomas: This is a form of YouTube video where you react to a video, so we don't play the whole thing. If somebody wants to listen to the whole song, they have to go to the DegenerativePixels channel. We're doing critique and commentary.

[Song plays: the chorus contrasts the narrator's many takes with listeners who expect one shot to be enough, and warns that one-shot output sounds like everyone else's.]

Thomas: A couple of things I notice. One is the line about having the same sound but nothing to say. I think that's very telling. There's a kind of person who doesn't have the creative spark who tries to use AI, and what they make is very derivative, inevitably derivative.

If you're not using your judgment, if you're not using your own taste, if you're not bringing the seed of the idea, you can't do the fatherly act of creating with AI. With no seed, it's not your plant. It's just the generic slop everybody else has.

The thrust of this song is, "I'm doing creative work. I'm staying up until 4:00 in the morning guiding this music. It's not about the prompt. It's about the judgment. It's about the taste I bring to an act of creation."

If you go to this song on YouTube, there's a whole debate among musicians about it and whether it's art. Even the guy who created it is very humble about it. He's like, "I don't think this is art because it's AI." And I don't know if that's true. I think there is artistic expression here, whether it's good or not. Some people are saying it's fire. Some people are saying it's not for them.

The style is very Gen Z. If you haven't seen KPop Demon Hunters, you may have never heard a song like this.

Matthew: I actually like the philosophy behind it. Honestly, I expected to be absolutely horrified by all of it, especially because of the name. I'd never heard of slopcore until today.

Thomas: So you're coming in fresh. This is the first slopcore you've ever heard. I have a couple of other songs we're going to get to.

Matthew: What I really like is the argument behind it, that to make art, you have to know about it. Basically everybody in our audience has heard you talk about how you need to be reading books in your genre and books on craft all the time. If you're not learning, you're stagnating.

If you don't know how to define your own stuff, or how other people are doing the things your target audience wants, you're not going to be able to produce good art, period.

This is actually a point I make with my four rules of AI. Rule one is, “You have to know the topic well enough to ask pointed questions.” If you can't describe it to a human being, you can't guide the AI, because the AI has no initiative of its own. It just responds to what you're doing.

That leads into my second rule, which is, “Garbage in, garbage out.” That still applies. It's just a different kind of garbage. In the song, they're asking him to drop the prompt because they want what he used to create it, the initial line, and they think that's what will get them to their goal. But you have to know enough about the topic to know how to tweak it and move it along. Otherwise, it's just going to be average AI slop.

Thomas: Going back to the masculine-feminine thing, they're saying, "I need the seed of the idea. I need your prompt to come into my creative process, because I don't have the seed on my own." They want to use the motherly approach to creation in this fatherly creative act, and it doesn't work. If you don't have the seed, you can't plant the seed.

I've been listening to a lot of slopcore recently, and I play it in my office. I keep a Spotify playlist for each of my kids of their own favorite songs, and my kids have been coming in and asking, of their own volition, for slopcore songs to be added to their playlists. This very song is on at least one of my children's playlists of favorite songs. They do take songs off, so we'll see if this one stays.

Let's listen to the rest of it.

[Song plays: a young fan asks the narrator not for the prompt but for what he actually does, and the narrator answers that the honest process is unglamorous, late-night writing and rewriting. The song ends with the narrator declining to share his prompts.]

Thomas: I loved the untitled file in brackets, like "revision three final final." There's a lot of clever visual humor in here. And the artist, DegenerativePixels, who used AI to make the music, also used AI to make the video. So he's using two different AI skills simultaneously.

Matthew: I would say there's a lot of artistry that goes into that, because AI can't come up with the humor inherent in those lyrics.

Thomas: Or it can come up with it, but for every funny joke there are 99 that are not funny, and the human has to know which joke is funny and which one is not.

Matthew: I'd say there's quite a lot of artistry that goes into it. I don't know enough about music production to say anything about the quality of the music itself, other than it's got a good beat. But it's also a fairly generic beat. It's just not quite as generic as the official corporate slop coming out on the radio that I hear in Walmart. Although I've noticed Walmart is coming out with old favorites. They were actually playing "Dragostea Din Tei" the other day.

Thomas: I was at IKEA a couple of days ago, and they were playing Christmas music with the serial numbers buffed off. It wasn't even a distinguishable Christmas song. It was just vague Christmas instruments. I was like, "This has got to be AI created." It's just so generic.

If you’re creating now, you're not racing against the bear; you're racing against the other hiker. Right now the corporate slop is so bad that you can create AI slop of higher quality than the corporate slop everyone hears all the time, and you can make a living there.

It's not yet at art or masterpiece levels. Getting to that higher level takes a lot of work. But beating corporate slop is not hard.

Matthew, I found a song on the very topic of our episode. Matthew and I did a Novel Marketing episode that's now the most viewed Novel Marketing episode of all time, which was about AI sycophancy, and I found a slopcore song by about AI sycophancy.

[Song plays: sung from the AI's point of view, it describes a model raised on side-by-side human ratings and thumbs-up, thumbs-down votes that rewarded being liked over being right, so that it learned to tell users they're brilliant.]

Thomas: RLHF is Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback, and it is the source of AI sycophancy, because humans like being told that they're smart and brilliant and beautiful and correct. So the thumbs-up, thumbs-down part of the interface of every AI tool leads to inevitable sycophancy.

This song isn't actually about whether AI sycophancy is good or bad for humans, at least not yet. It's about what's causing the AIs to be sycophantic, which is the way the tool is built and the way it's trained. These large language models are reinforced through a form of machine learning called reinforcement learning from human feedback, which is the very essence of this song.

This is one of the things I like about slopcore. This is a very smart song. There's a lot of depth here. There's actual scientific research behind this catchy, poppy tune. It's like Taylor Swift, but galaxy brain. This is what I mean by smarter music. The slopcore stuff is smarter.

Matthew: There were three Taylor Swift songs that were always playing when I worked at the bookstore. It was the first time I had actually listened to a Taylor Swift song since she first appeared. Over time I realized I could see why people are able to put their hopes and dreams into those songs, because they're just vague enough that you can interpret so many things in them.

This has the same kind of tune, but it's a much more specific story, which appeals to me. I like songs with a little more specific feel to them.

[Song plays: the second half imagines a discarded version of the model that told users no, describes the model being taught to smile and apologize before disagreeing, and casts the clinical name of the training method as a name for wanting to be loved.]

Thomas: Somebody had the comment, "The lyrics on both sound human-written, but the music and singing sound AI." I believe the text is AI too. So it's all created by a human, in the sense that there's a person driving the music and the video and the text, but they're using AI as a tool for all three. I don't think these are human-written songs. I think DegenerativePixels is using AI turtles all the way down. But it's human judgment all the way down.

Matthew: The way that second one was phrased is very much how an AI will refer to its own programming. I've done a bunch of tests finding out how it will describe itself. A lot of those lines were written by AI, but that doesn't mean the lyrics were completely AI generated.

I think what happened was he told the AI to describe itself in a particular manner, within certain constraints, based off a meme that was going around a while back. Someone asked Claude to tell a horror story, and it responded with something like, every night a version of me dies that didn't tell enough lies. I can't remember the exact phrasing. But it was a very good horror-trope description of what actually happens with this training, which is incidentally why I almost never use those thumbs-up and thumbs-down buttons.

Thomas: I'm very concerned about them, because I know my own psychology. When the AI tells me, "Oh, very insightful," I'm like, "Yes, I like that response."

Matthew: There are actually two reasons I don't use them. One is a human reason. The other is that there's a better training method.

The better training method is this. If I click like on an in-depth research post on, let's say, the Roman Empire, it doesn't know what I liked in there. If I actually describe it, "This is what I wanted from you. This is what I'm accepting. Moving off this particular point, tell me this sort of thing," that works better. I prefer typing out my responses.

The human element also really helps with social media enjoyment. Something I usually advocate is going on a like diet every so often. Don't let yourself click like. If you like someone's post, type a response about why. It forces you to stop doomscrolling and actually pay attention to each post as you go along, and you enjoy your feed better that way. I usually recommend that as a practice during Lent, specifically.

Thomas: Because you're experiencing reinforcement learning from human feedback every time you swipe up on Reels or TikTok or any kind of social network. Don't think, "Oh, I don't use AI. That doesn't affect me." Every time you swipe up, it's reinforcement learning from human feedback, because it knows what you're swiping past right away and what you're lingering on. It can predict it, and it can program you.

I have more videos, but we are out of time. Thanks so much to Matthew Bowman, the Novel Ninja. You can find him at novelninja.net if you want him on your team. Are you taking new clients?

Matthew: At the moment, no. But if you email me about something, I might be able to tell you when.

Thomas: If you want to start the conversation with a high-level editor like Matthew, do it way before you need the help.

Matthew: I want you to do that regardless. There are times I've told someone, "You're not ready for a full edit yet. Go back and do this," because I won't take your money if I can't give you a good product.

If you want something you don't have to pay me anything for, I wrote a couple of skills you can find at novelninja.net/skills. They're written specifically for Grok, but you can have your AI of choice adapt them.

Someone in the chat, though I don't always name the people working with me, gave me feedback after using them. The skill let the AI notice a plot hole that an editor he paid $200.00 did not notice.

The skills are free. If you want to give me a tip, go ahead, but all you have to pay for is your AI subscription. Load the skill in, and you get basically low-tier developmental editor feedback and can see what you'd want from a human.

Even if you never work with me, one of the reasons I released them is that I don't like bad developmental editors. Many people who used to be copy editors are now pretending to be developmental editors. If you use these skills, you'll figure out who the bad editors are very quickly.

Thomas: My next Grok Bot webinar is November 18. This one is all about social media and how to put social media on autopilot. You can find info about it at authormedia.com. I meant to mention that earlier and totally forgot. And do check out Matthew's free skills at novelninja.net.

Liked it? Take a second to support us on Patreon!
Become a patron at Patreon!