Jonathan: It’s Christmas time, which means everyone turns on their Hallmark movies, and I have to sit through the same flannel-wearing protagonist who somehow outshines the high-powered executive.
Thomas: How is everyone in this small town so attractive?
Jonathan: The report profiles 7,050 titles within a total market of about 32,000 titles. Monthly royalties are approximately $1.83 million, not including Kindle Unlimited page reads.
The top-performing title averages about 2,300 sales per day. By the time you reach the number 1,000 title, sales drop to around 3.9 per day. You really need to be near the top of the category to see meaningful results.
Google search interest for Christmas romance is trending upward, but there was a major supply spike in October from low-quality, AI-generated titles. That’s not surprising. There are so many Hallmark-style Christmas stories that AI can easily imitate the formula.
About 50% of September 2025 releases had zero or one review. That’s often a signal of AI-generated books, since AI doesn’t have friends or family to leave early reviews and make the book appear legitimate.
What do we really mean by “AI-generated books”?
Thomas: When we say “AI-generated,” what we usually mean is that there’s a person producing a book a day under dozens of pen names and putting no effort into marketing.
The strategy is to flood Amazon and let its machine learning algorithms decide which books succeed. It’s essentially buying a large number of cheap lottery tickets and hoping one hits.
What strategy should authors use for Christmas romance in 2025?
Jonathan: K-lytics recommends prioritizing Kindle Unlimited enrollment. About 84% of Christmas romance royalties come from Kindle Unlimited, which reflects the broader romance market right now.
Focus on series rather than standalones. Series like Evergreen Hollow by Fiona Baker and Mistletoe Meadows by Jenna Guzman are performing well. Series improve reader retention and allow you to benefit from Amazon’s built-in recommendation system with each new release.
Aim for 200 to 300 pages to align with distribution peaks in the genre. Price strategically. Top titles tend to average $3.99 to $5.99, with occasional $0.99 promotions to boost visibility.
Category optimization matters, and the report breaks that down in detail. Cover trends are also important. Interestingly, covers without people are currently outperforming covers with people. If you do use people, you need to be deliberate about whether you feature a single character or a couple.
What can Hallmark movies teach authors about book covers?
Thomas: Part of the success of Hallmark Christmas movies is what’s happening behind the actors. If you pause almost any frame, it looks like a Christmas card.
There are Christmas trees everywhere, lights everywhere. My wife and I were watching The Mistletoe Murders, which is surprisingly good for a Hallmark-style mystery.
At one point, the protagonist is interviewing a janitor in a break room, and there’s a Christmas tree behind him. She even comments on it. That tree is positioned so that whenever the heroine is on screen, there’s a softly blurred Christmas tree glowing in the background.
That constant visual reinforcement creates a strong seasonal atmosphere. Giving your book cover that same unmistakable Christmas feel is critical in this genre.
Thomas: For more detail, check out the K-lytics report. We have an K-lytics.com affiliate link, which helps support us and Alex, who runs K-lytics, and generously allows us to summarize his research.
We’ve only shared the highlights here. There’s a lot more data in the full report. Now is actually a great time to start brainstorming ideas for a Christmas romance to release next year.
Zeigeist: K-Lytics Paranormal Romance Report
Thomas: Paranormal romance is being flooded with AI slop. This segment may not be family friendly, but we’ll keep it as clean as we can while acknowledging how degenerate romance fiction has become. The level of degeneracy is staggering.
Jonathan: Paranormal romance has been around for years. It generally refers to romances that involve something outside the normal world. That includes shifter romances, alien romances, and dark urban fantasy romances. Twilight technically falls into paranormal romance and can probably be credited with popularizing the genre.
Romantasy has largely eclipsed paranormal romance in my mind. The two are closely related, though they do have different buying patterns. Readers often draw a distinction between them, even if the lines blur.
Thomas: Paranormal romance is typically rooted in the real world with supernatural elements added. Romantasy usually takes place entirely in a different world. Think of The Chronicles of Narnia as paranormal in some respects, because the children start in the real world and cross over. It’s portal fantasy. The Lord of the Rings, by contrast, is pure fantasy with no direct connection to our world.
What emotional need does paranormal romance fulfill?
Jonathan: Paranormal romance asks the question, “What if the world I lived in was cooler?” What if the cute barista were a werewolf with a dark past who struggles with his inner nature?
That speaks to a cultural hunger for the otherworldly, or what I’d call the transcendent. Google Ngram data shows mentions of paranormal romance rising sharply since the early 2000s. That rise coincides with global upheaval, economic recessions, pandemics, and social unrest.
When the real world feels broken, people want a world that feels better or more meaningful. Supernatural elements become metaphors for resilience and permanence. Vampires endure eternity, which makes love feel lasting and secure. Vampire romances often emphasize eternal commitment, reincarnation, and soulmates. That idea of the fated one is deeply romantic, especially when paired with immortal beings who can wait forever.
Thomas: Paranormal romance and Christmas romance intersect in The Nutcracker. Clara begins in the real world at a Christmas party, falls asleep, and enters a supernatural conflict between fae factions. She’s transported to the winter court and encounters the Sugar Plum Fairy.
What’s fascinating is how deeply fairy mythology is embedded in that story. Clara breaks every rule of dealing with the fae. She eats their food and makes implicit agreements. In folklore, that means she’s never going home. The story ends with her still in the fairy world, with no indication she survives or returns.
How have paranormal romance tropes changed?
Jonathan: The dominant tropes have shifted. We’ve moved away from pure alpha dominance toward empowered bonds. Current keywords include fated, rejected, alpha shifter, reverse harem, omegaverse, fae, and bonds.
These tropes emphasize destiny, ownership, power, and danger. There’s a strong sense of being claimed by fate or by a powerful partner. Many of these themes reflect dating app fatigue. Readers are tired of endless swiping and want a story where the perfect partner is destined, not negotiated.
Which classic tropes are disappearing?
Jonathan: Someone asked why “enemies to lovers” isn’t as dominant anymore. In contemporary feminist discourse, the message is often “trust your instincts.” If someone is dangerous or disrespectful, the story no longer redeems them.
Enemies-to-lovers can now feel like endorsing abuse. Instead, we see strong female protagonists paired with powerful male characters, where abuse is not tolerated. Honestly, I’m in favor of that shift.
Thomas: That said, the alpha males in these stories are often very dark. There’s a lot of dark romance inside paranormal romance. According to K-lytics data from Alex, 62% of new paranormal romance titles released in September were likely junk AI books. That’s an enormous percentage.
Why is AI flooding this genre so aggressively?
Jonathan: Paranormal romance already had a culture of rapid release. AI tools just accelerated that trend. What used to be two books a month can now become thirty books a month.
Thomas: Romance is seen in AI circles as the easiest genre to automate because it’s so formulaic. While AI slop exists everywhere, romance, especially paranormal and dark romance, is being hit first and hardest.
Where is the genre heading next?
Jonathan: The most successful paranormal titles now blur genre lines. There’s overlap with romantic urban fantasy and cozy mystery. Paranormal is also absorbing high fantasy elements for richer worldbuilding.
Books like Fourth Wing by Rebecca Yarros show how romantic fantasy can dominate, and paranormal authors are borrowing from that success through portal fantasy structures. Search terms are increasingly mixing “cozy” with “paranormal.” The cultural mood is softening. Readers still want escapism, but not constant danger.
Thomas: Consumer sentiment is historically low, even though the economy looks strong on paper. The stock market is up, gas is cheaper, groceries are cheaper, but people feel bad. The vibes are off.
That matters. Reader behavior changes based on emotional climate. During low-vibe periods, people gravitate toward different kinds of stories. That’s why genres like billionaire romance and paranormal romance overlap. Sometimes he’s a billionaire and a vampire.
Jonathan: Billionaire romance works like portal fantasy. Dating the billionaire moves you from a dead-end job into a different world, yachts and elite society included. That’s the same appeal as Pretty Woman, Enchanted, or Elf. Someone from one world enters another and transforms it.
What should authors take away from this trend?
Thomas: All books are portals in some sense. You’re taking readers into a world you’ve created. In times of stress, readers want to escape to a world that feels better, or to bring something hopeful into a broken one. Stories that do that well, that demonstrate what is good, true and beautiful, especially during the Christmas season, are likely to resonate.
YouTube Version
